This is about the frequency of integral solutions to $$ b^2 - 4 a^3 = \Delta, $$ when $\Delta < 0$ is a discriminant of positive binary quadratic forms such that the class number is divisible by 3. My observation is that integral solutions are pretty frequent when $|\Delta|$ is small. For instance, there are 25 discriminants with class number exactly 3. Of these, in 19 cases we can write the non-principal, order three form as $$ \langle a, \pm b, a^2 \rangle, $$ the failures seeming to be $$ \Delta = -124, \; -172, \; -307, \; -547, \; -652, \; 907,$$ with the first two proved impossible in integers, maybe all six.

Note that there may be multiple solutions for a given $\Delta,$ which usually means the forms reduce to the same thing or the principal form, as in $$ \langle 2, 1, 4 \rangle = \langle 4, 15, 16 \rangle $$ but $$ \langle 10, 63, 100 \rangle = \langle 1, 1, 8 \rangle. $$ On the other hand, in the relatively rare event of 3-rank larger than one, we may have genuinely distinct cube roots of 1, and for $\Delta = -3299$ we find
$$ \langle 11,45, 121 \rangle = \langle 11, 1, 75 \rangle, $$ $$ \langle 15, 101, 225 \rangle = \langle 15, 11, 57 \rangle, $$
$$ \langle 23, 213, 529 \rangle = \langle 23, -17, 39 \rangle. $$

So, the question is, how likely is it that a positive form of order three in the class group can be written as $$ f(x,y) = a x^2 + b x y + a^2 y^2 ? $$

EDIT: of course this becomes Mordell's equation when $\Delta$ is even, which is how I know there are proofs for $-124, -172$ but a rational solution $a = 1177/36, \; b = 40355/108$ for $-172.$ Hope I got the factor of 2 in the right place.

EDIT TOOOOO: forgot. by Dirichlet's "united forms" description of composition, $$ \langle a,b,a^2 \rangle^2 = \langle a^2, b,a \rangle, $$ so such a form is either the principal form or of order three, as long as $$ \gcd(a,b) = 1. $$

EDIT THREE, Saturday: The importance of this for my other recent questions appeared when I found that $ \langle 4,1,9 \rangle$ integrally represents 77, but $ \langle 4,1,9 \rangle + \langle 4,1,9 \rangle,$ or $g(x,y,z,w) = 4 x^2 + x y + 9 y^2 + 4 z^2 + z w + 9 w^2,$ does not represent $77^2 = 5929.$ Now, $ \langle 4,1,9 \rangle$ has order five, so the set of values it represents is not required to be multiplicative. Similarly, if $f$ is of order 2 "ambiguous," it seems always true that $f$ represents some $n$ (often prime) while $f(x,y) + f(z,w)$ fails to represent $n^2.$ Note that the original form in question 88905 is of order three, indeed $$ \langle 4,2, 3 \rangle = \langle 3,-2,4 \rangle = \langle 3,-8,9 \rangle. $$ So three seems to be the order of the day.


1 Answer 1


If you treat $b^2-4a^3=\Delta$ as an elliptic curve, say $E_\Delta$, then of course there are only finitely many integer points on $E_\Delta$ (effectively by Baker). But since you're interested in the number of solutions, then possibly it's useful to know that under the assumption that $\Delta$ is 6'th power free, there exists an absolute constant $C$ such that $$\#E_\Delta(\mathbb{Z})\le C^{1+\hbox{rank }E_\Delta(\mathbb{Q})}.$$ [J. Reine angew. Math 378 (1987), 60-100.] Actually, you can probably relax the 6'th power free assumption on $\Delta$ if you restrict to integer solutions such that $\gcd(a^2,b^3)$ is 6'th power free.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, Joe. I realized at some point that there were various possible subquestions, and that I may not have hit quite the right note. As $n \rightarrow -\infty,$ both the count of possible values of $0 \geq b^2 - 4 a^3 \geq n$ and the number of discriminants with class number divisible by 3 with $0 \geq \Delta \geq n$ go to infinity. What I had in mind was, given class number divisible by 3, is there a nonzero likelihood that there is any solution at all to $b^2 - 4 a^3 = \Delta?$ I admit, this does not end things, for example you may just be rewriting the principal form... $\endgroup$
    – Will Jagy
    Mar 4, 2012 at 0:31
  • $\begingroup$ @W.Jagy: On average one expects zero integral solutions as $|\Delta| \rightarrow \infty$, and I think this can be proved under the ABC conjecture, or just Hall's conjecture; more precisely, there should be only $O(n^{5/6 + \epsilon})$ solutions of $|b^2 - 4a^3| \leq n$ (and it's easy to show the number of solutions is $\gg n^{5/6}$). $\endgroup$ Mar 4, 2012 at 2:42

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.