4
$\begingroup$

$\DeclareMathOperator\cl{cl}$Let $X$ be a topological space and let $Y$ be a dense subspace of $X$. Suppose that $R\left( X\right) $ denotes all regular closed subsets of $X$.

Question 1: $R\left( Y\right) \longrightarrow R\left( X\right) $, $A\rightarrow \cl_{X}A$ is bijective.

Question 2: If $A$ is regular closed in $Y$, then $\cl_{X}A$ is the unique regular closed subset of $X$ with $A=Y\cap \cl_{X}A$.

Can you answer these questions?

$\endgroup$

1 Answer 1

4
$\begingroup$

The answer to both of these questions is Yes. And this result can generalize to point-free topology and I consider this result to be more natural in the context of point-free topology.

The following observations were produced earlier by Mehmet Onat, so let me paraphrase those arguments.

Observation: If $U$ is an open subset of $X$ and $Y$ is dense in $X$, then $\text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)=\text{Cl}_X(U)$.

Proof: Clearly $\text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)\subseteq\text{Cl}_X(U)$. For the converse direction, suppose that $a\in\text{Cl}_X(U)$. Then whenever $O$ is an open subset of $X$ that contains $a$, we have $O\cap U\neq\emptyset$. However, since $Y$ is dense in $X$, we also know that $O\cap U\cap Y\neq\emptyset$. Therefore, $a\in\text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)$, so we may conclude the converse $\text{Cl}_X(U)\subseteq \text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y).$ $\square$

Claim: Suppose that $Y$ is dense in $X$. If $C\in R(Y)$, then $\text{Cl}_X(C)\in R(X)$.

Proof: If $C\in R(Y)$, then there is some open subset $U\subseteq X$ where $$C=\text{Cl}_Y(U\cap Y)=\text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)\cap Y=\text{Cl}_X(U)\cap Y.$$

Therefore, $$\text{Cl}_X(C)=\text{Cl}_X(\text{Cl}_X(U)\cap Y)\supseteq \text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)=\text{Cl}_X(U)=\text{Cl}_X(\text{Cl}_X(U))$$ $$\supseteq\text{Cl}_X(\text{Cl}_X(U)\cap Y)=\text{Cl}_X(C),$$ so $\text{Cl}_X(C)=\text{Cl}_X(U)$ which is regular closed. $\square$

Claim: If $C\in R(X)$, then $C\cap Y\in R(Y)$

Proof: Since $C\in R(X)$, we have $C=\text{Cl}_X(U)$ for some open $U\subseteq X$. Therefore, $$R(Y)\ni\text{Cl}_Y(U\cap Y)=\text{Cl}_X(U\cap Y)\cap Y=\text{Cl}_X(U)\cap Y=C\cap Y.$$ $\square.$

If $X$ is a topological space and $Y\subseteq X$ is dense, then let $i_{Y,X}:R(Y)\rightarrow R(X)$ be the mapping defined by $i_{Y,X}(C)=\text{Cl}_X(C)$ and define a mapping $j_{X,Y}:R(X)\rightarrow R(Y)$ by letting $j_{X,Y}(C)=C\cap Y$.

Claim: The mapping $i_{Y,X}$ is injective. More generally, if $C,D$ are distinct closed subsets of $Y$, then $\text{Cl}_X(C)\neq\text{Cl}_X(D)$.

Proof: We can assume that $x_0\in C\setminus D$. Then since $Y\setminus D$ is open in $Y$, there is an open set $U\subseteq X$ where $U\cap Y=Y\setminus D$. Therefore, since $U\cap D=\emptyset$, we have $U\cap\text{Cl}_X(D)=\emptyset$ as well, so $x_0\in\text{Cl}_X(C)$, but $x_0\not\in\text{Cl}_X(D)$. Therefore, the mapping $R(Y)\rightarrow R(X),C\mapsto\text{Cl}_X(C)$ is injective. Mehmet Onat observed that injectivity also follows from the fact that $C=\text{Cl}_Y(C)=Y\cap\text{Cl}_X(C)$. $\square$

Claim: If $C\in R(X)$, then $i_{Y,X}(j_{X,Y}(C))=C$. Therefore, the mappings $i_{Y,X},j_{X,Y}$ are inverses.

Proof: Clearly, $\text{Cl}_X(C\cap Y)\subseteq C$. For the converse direction, suppose that $x_0\in C$. Suppose now that $U$ is an open subset of $X$ with $x_0\in U$. Then since $C=\overline{C^\circ}$, we know that $U\cap C^\circ\neq\emptyset$. Since $U\cap C^\circ\neq\emptyset$ and $U\cap C^\circ$ is open, we know that $U\cap C^\circ\cap Y\neq\emptyset$ since $Y$ is dense in $X$. Therefore, since $U$ is an arbitrary neighborhood of $x_0$, we have $x_0\in\overline{C^\circ\cap Y}\subseteq\overline{C\cap Y}$. Therefore, $C=\text{Cl}_X(C\cap Y)$. Q.E.D.

Forcing and point-free topology

Let $X$ be a regular space, and let $D$ be the intersection of all open dense subsets of $X$. If $X$ has no isolated points and is $T_1$, then $D$ is empty, but $D$ has virtual points, and $R(X)$ is isomorphic to the lattice of closed subsets of the space $D$. The virtual points of the space $D$ live inside forcing extensions $V[G].$ For example, the Boolean valued model $V^{R[X]}$ always adds points to the space $D$.

If $L$ is a frame, then let $B_L=\{x^{**}\mid x\in L\}=\{x^*\mid x\in L\}$ where $^*$ is the pseudocomplement operation. Then $B_L$ is a complete Boolean algebra which is the point-free analogue to the lattice of all regular open (and also the lattice of regular closed) subsets of $X$. We say that a sublocale $S$ of a frame $L$ is dense if $0\in S$. The frame $B_L$ is also a sublocale of $L$, and $B_L$ is the smallest dense sublocale of $L.$ A frame is fit if and only if each sublocale is the intersection of open sublocales, so in a fit frame $L$, the Boolean algebra $B_L$ is the intersection of all open sublocales of $L$. If $S$ is a sublocale of a frame $L$, then the Heyting operation on $S$ is the same as the Heyting operation on $L$. In particular, if $S$ is a dense sublocale of $L$, then the pseudocomplement operation on $S$ coincides with the pseudocomplement operation on $S$. Therefore, if $S$ is a dense sublocale of a frame $L$, then $B_S=B_L$.

$\endgroup$
8
  • $\begingroup$ For injectivity, more simply, if $cl_{X}A=cl_{X}B\Rightarrow A=cl_{Y}A=cl_{X}A\cap Y=cl_{X}B\cap Y=cl_{Y}B=B$. $\endgroup$ Commented Apr 8, 2023 at 21:18
  • $\begingroup$ one more thing to show that if $A\in R\left( Y\right) $ then $cl_{X}A\in R\left( X\right) ?$ $\endgroup$ Commented Apr 8, 2023 at 21:34
  • $\begingroup$ Moreover, if if $C\in R\left( X\right) $ then $C \cap Y\in R\left( Y\right) ?$. it is needed in surjectivity or in the inverse map. $\endgroup$ Commented Apr 8, 2023 at 21:54
  • $\begingroup$ if $A\in R\left( X\right) $ then $cl_{X}Int_{X}A=A$. And $Int_{X}A\cap Y\subset Int_{Y}\left( A\cap Y\right) \subset A\cap Y$ $\Rightarrow cl_{Y}\left( Int_{X}A\cap Y\right) \subset cl_{Y}Int_{Y}\left( A\cap Y\right) \subset A\cap Y$. $\endgroup$ Commented Apr 9, 2023 at 1:39
  • $\begingroup$ On the other hand, $cl_{Y}\left( Int_{X}A\cap Y\right) =cl_{X}\left( Int_{X}A\cap Y\right) \cap Y$ and since $% Y$ is dense in $X$, then $cl_{X}\left( Int_{X}A\cap Y\right) =cl_{X}\left( Int_{X}A\right) \cap Y=A\cap Y$. Hence $A\cap Y\subset cl_{Y}Int_{Y}\left( A\cap Y\right) \subset A\cap Y$, so $cl_{Y}Int_{Y}\left( A\cap Y\right) =A\cap Y$, then $A\cap Y$ is regular closed in $Y$. $\endgroup$ Commented Apr 9, 2023 at 1:40

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .