Let $G$ be a finite group, $A$ some coefficients (e.g. $A = \mathbb{F}_2$ or $\mathbb{Z}$), and write $\mathrm{H}^\bullet_{\mathrm{gp}}(G; A)$ for the (ordinary) group cohomology of $G$ with coefficients in $A$. Recall that a class $\alpha \in \mathrm{H}^\bullet_{\mathrm{gp}}(G; A)$ is essential if it is nonzero, but the restriction $\alpha|_S \in \mathrm{H}^\bullet_{\mathrm{gp}}(S; A)$ is zero for all proper subgroups $S \subsetneq G$. For example, a standard lemma shows that $G$ has no essential cohomology if $G$ is not a $p$-group for some prime $p$ (as the collection of Sylow $p$-subgroups together detect all cohomology). On the other hand, for a cyclic group of prime order, all classes are essential, just because the group has no subgroups.

General question: Which groups have essential cohomology of low degree?

The question is basically trivial in degree $1$. Indeed, $\mathrm{H}^1_{\mathrm{gp}}(G; A) = \hom(G, A)$, and a nonzero homomorphism takes a nonzero value on some element, so the only groups with essential cohomology in degree $1$ are cyclic (and these do have essential cohomology). Moreover, it's approximately true that an abelian group has essential cohomology of degree $d$ when it has rank $d$; compare Which groups have undetectable third U(1)-cohomology?.

Specific question: Which groups have essential classes in $\mathrm{H}^2_{\mathrm{gp}}(-; \mathbb{F}_2)$?

  • $\begingroup$ @ChrisGerig Awesome. And your Proposition 2.2 already answers all questions about $\mathbb{F}_2$-cohomology (or rather it moves them to ring theoretic questions, which in any specific low degree I can compute directly). $\endgroup$ Aug 23, 2022 at 18:03

2 Answers 2


Call a finite $p$ group $G$ $p$--central if every element of order $p$ is central.

In a 1997 Comm. Math. Helv. paper, A. Adem and D. Karagueuzian proved that every $p$--central group has essential mod $p$ cohomology. I got at this theorem in a different way in [N.J.Kuhn, Adv. Math. 216 (2007), 387--442], with a result that defines a number $e(G)$ that gives the degree of a particular essential element with other nice properties (e.g. it is acted on trivially by all Steenrod operations).

So what is this number $e(G)$? Let $C$ be the (unique) maximal elementary abelian subgroup of $G$: the nontrivial elements of $C$ are all the elements of $G$ of order $p$. Then $e(G)$ is determined by the image of the restriction $ H^*(G;\mathbb Z/p) \rightarrow H^*(C;\mathbb Z/p)$, which is always a sub-Hopf algebra of $H^*(C;\mathbb Z/p)$. More precisely, $e(G)$ is the top degree of the finite dimensional Hopf algebra $H^*(C;\mathbb Z/p) \otimes_{H^*(G;\mathbb Z/p)} \mathbb Z/p$, and is often quite easy to compute.

$e(G)$ is often quite easy to compute, and, in tables in an appendix of the paper, I list the values of $e(G)$ for all $2$--central $2$--groups of order up through 64. In particular, the following indecomposable 2-groups have $e(G)=2$, and thus essential classes in degree 2: groups of order 32 with Hall-Senior numbers 19, 21, 29, and 30, and groups of order 64 with Hall-Senior numbers 38, 39, 41, 64, 65, 140, and 141.

A general result would go: Proposition Let $G$ be a $2$--central group with $C$ of rank 2. If the image of the restriction map (as above) is polynomial on two classes in dimension $2$, then $e(G)=2$ and so there is essential cohomology in degree 2.

None of this is very trivial. Read my paper (and a later follow-up of mine on nilpotence in cohomology) if your are interested. The theory is worked out at odd primes too; I was just obsessed with $2$-groups as I looked for examples. I should also say that I was not looking for the essential cohomology class of lowest degree; indeed, my class is likely the essential class of greatest degree.


If I were to attempt a general p-group classification I'd use the theory of extensions (for degree 2). Regardless, I wrote a paper as an undergrad to compute the essential cohomology of a sub-classification (all p-groups with a cyclic subgroup of index p) from which you can read off what you want: https://arxiv.org/abs/1006.4836. Likewise a sub-classification for elementary abelian p-groups was given by Aksu-Green 2009, and for extraspecial p-groups by Minh 2000.

For p = 2 there is another classical result (due to Marx 1990 but probably Quillen knew it) that handles mod 2 essential cohomology in all degrees: $$Ess(G)=\bigcap\lbrace(x)\;|\;x\in H^1(G;\mathbb Z/2\mathbb Z)\rbrace$$

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @Theo You can reach out to me if you're interested in related concepts: Back then I was thinking about what I call "virtually essential cohomology" (where you ignore maximal subgroups) and formed a filtration on group cohomology, but neither me nor Ken Brown found a use for it. $\endgroup$ Aug 23, 2022 at 19:49

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.