Let $X ⊆ \mathbb{P}^n$ be a smooth projective variety (over $\mathbb{C}$). I think we can find a chain of irreducible varieties $X = X_0 ⊆ X_1 ⊆ X_2 ⊆ \cdots ⊆ X_k = \mathbb{P}^n$ whose dimension increases by one at every step by writing $X = \mathcal{V}(f_1, \dots, f_n)$ and dropping some of the $f_i$ until the dimension of the irreducible component containing $X$ increases, and then proceeding by induction on $k = \operatorname{codim}(X)$.

Is it possible to a chain where all of the $X_i$ are smooth?


3 Answers 3


Suppose that $\operatorname{dim}(X)>1$ and that such a chain exists. Since $\operatorname{Pic}(\mathbf{P}^n)\simeq \mathbf{Z}$, the variety $X_{k-1}$ is an ample divisor in $\mathbf{P}^n$, and hence by the Lefschetz hyperplane theorem we have $\operatorname{Pic}(X_{k-1})\simeq \mathbf{Z}$. So $X_{k-2}$ is an ample divisor on $X_{k-1}$, and again its Picard group is $\mathbf{Z}$. By induction, we obtain that each $X_{i-1}$ is an ample divisor on $X_{i}$, and then by hyperplane Lefschetz for $\pi_1$ we obtain that $\pi_1(X)\simeq \pi_1(\mathbf{P}^n)$ is the trivial group. So to conclude, an abelian variety of dimension at least two embedded in $\mathbf{P}^n$ gives a counterexample. (N.B. There exist abelian surfaces in $\mathbf{P}^4$, constructed by Horrocks and Mumford).

Edit. Of course this contradicts Sasha's answer posted roughly at the same time. I am puzzled as to where the mistake is.

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Indeed, my argument is incorrect (the explanation is given in the edit to my answer). $\endgroup$
    – Sasha
    Aug 10 at 9:15
  • $\begingroup$ I understand that this is outside scope but what about simply connected $X$? $\endgroup$ Aug 10 at 9:21
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @მამუკა ჯიბლაძე: No difference, there are smooth simply connected surfaces in $\Bbb{P}^4$ which are not complete intersections. $\endgroup$
    – abx
    Aug 10 at 9:36

There is already a complete and correct answer. I am just writing another answer since I am having trouble finding the old answer mentioned in my comment above. Update. Thanks to user @MinseonShin for finding the old answer: A Bertini-type result for hypersurfaces containing a subvariety

The question in the original post is a special case of the following question (which I believe was asked in a previous post).

Question. Is every smooth proper closed subvariety $X$ of a smooth projective variety $Y$ contained in a smooth hypersurface $Z$ in $Y$?

Proposition. If there exists a hypersurface $Z$ in $Y$ that contains $X$ and is smooth at every point of $X$, then the total Chern class $c(N_{X/Y})$ equals $(1+[Z]|_X)\cup \alpha$ for the total Chern class $\alpha$ of a locally free sheaf of rank $\text{dim}(Y)-(1+\text{dim}(X))$.

Proof. If there is such a hypersurface $Z$, then there is a short exact sequence of locally free sheaves on $X$, $$0 \to N_{X/Z} \to N_{X/Y} \to N_{Z/Y}|_X \to 0.$$ Then, by the Whitney sum formula, the total Chern class $c(N_{X/Y})$ equals $(1+[Z]|_X)\cup c(N_{X/Z})$. QED

This fails in many cases. For instance, for the embedding of a $2$-plane $X$ in a smooth quadric hypersurface $Y$ in $\mathbb{P}^5$ (a Schubert subvariety of the Grassmannian $\text{Gr}(2,4)$, in other words), this gives, $$1+H+H^2 = (1+mH)(1+nH) = 1+(m+n)H +mnH^2,$$ for integers $m$ and $n$. Clearly this has no solution in integers, thus there is no hypersurface $Z$ in $Y$ that contains $X$ and is smooth at every point of $X$. (Note, the restriction map on Picard groups from $Y$ to $X$ is an isomorphism in this example.)


EDIT. The argument below is incorrect. Indeed, for smoothness of a divisor along $X$ one needs the zero locus of a section of $I_X/I_X^2(mH)$ to be empty (not just smooth), and this typically is impossible when the rank of this bundle (equal to $\mathrm{codim}(X)$) is less or equal than $\dim(X)$.

Yes, this follows from Bertini's Theorem.

Indeed, let us check that if $X \subset Y$ is an embedding of smooth projective varieties then there is a smooth divisor $D \subset Y$ containing $X$ (then we will proceed by induction). Indeed, let $I_X$ be the ideal of $X$ and let $H$ be an ample divisor class on $Y$. Then for $m \gg 0$ the sheaf $I_X(mH)$ is globally generated, hence by Bertini's Theorem on Y a general section of $I_X(mH)$ is a divisor smooth away from $X$.

On the other hand, for $m \gg 0$ we have $H^1(Y,I^2_X(mH)) = 0$, hence the morphism $$ H^0(Y,I_X(mH)) \to H^0(X,I_X/I_X^2(mH)) $$ is surjective, and the twisted conormal bundle $I_X/I_X^2(mH)$ is globally generated. Therefore, for a general its section (hence for general section of $I_X(mH)$) the zero locus on $X$ is also smooth (now by Bertini's Theorem on $X$), hence it is smooth everywhere.

Now, finally, we apply an inductive argument. First, we consider the embedding $X \subset X_k := \mathbb{P}^n$ and construct a smooth divisor $X_{k-1} \subset X_k$ containing $X$. Next we consider the embedding $X \subset X_{k-1}$ and construct a smooth divisor $X_{k-2} \subset X_{k-1}$ containing $X$. Iterating this procedure we construct the required chain.

  • 7
    $\begingroup$ I don't think that any smooth surface in $\mathbb{P}^4$ is contained in a smooth hypersurface, otherwise by Lefschetz theorem it would be a complete intersection? $\endgroup$
    – abx
    Aug 10 at 8:37
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @abx: You are absolutely right, my argument is incorrect (see the edit). $\endgroup$
    – Sasha
    Aug 10 at 9:14
  • $\begingroup$ Nevertheless, this is an interesting error (and instructive to me as I failed to detect it and probably would have if I had been refereeing a paper). $\endgroup$
    – Gro-Tsen
    Aug 10 at 12:02
  • $\begingroup$ This has come up before on MO (I can find a link). One obstruction to existence of a smooth hypersurface of degree $m$ containing $X$ is the image of the top Chern class of the normal bundle of $X$ inside the quotient of the Chow ring of $X$ by the principal ideal generated by $mc_1(\mathcal{O}(1))$. $\endgroup$ Aug 10 at 14:55

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.