MathOverflow is a question and answer site for professional mathematicians. Join them; it only takes a minute:

Sign up
Here's how it works:
  1. Anybody can ask a question
  2. Anybody can answer
  3. The best answers are voted up and rise to the top

Let G be a semisimple Lie group and let k be some number field. Let A be a finite index subgroup of some group B which is discrete and Zariski dense in G. Suppose A is in G(k). Then can we expect that B is in G(k') where k' is a finite Galois extension of k? When can we expect k'=k?

share|cite|improve this question
up vote 7 down vote accepted

I'll prove this when $G=SL(n,\mathbb{C})$. So assume $B\leq SL(n,\mathbb{C})$ is discrete, and $A\leq B$ is a finite-index subgroup. Let $A'\lhd A$ such that $A'\lhd B$ is the core, which is also finite index (by considering the kernel of the action on cosets of $A$ in $B$). Suppose that $A\subset SL(n,k)$ where $k$ is a number field, and assume that $k$ is the smallest field containing the entries of $A$. Since $B$ is Zariski dense in $SL(n)$, $A'$ is also Zariski dense. Take a maximal collection $a_1,\ldots, a_m\in A'$ of linearly independent elements. Since $A$ is finite index in $B$, the field generated over $\mathbb{Q}$ by the entries of $B$ will be spanned over $k$ by the entries of finitely many coset representatives of $A$ in $B$, and therefore will be a finitely generated extension field $k'$ of $k$. Consider the variety $X$ of representations $\rho:B\to SL(n,\mathbb{C})$ such that $\rho_{| A}=Id$. This is a variety again, because it is determined by finitely many matrices which are coset representatives of $A$ in $B$. Considering the fact that $\rho(b)^{-1} a_i \rho(b)=\rho(b^{-1}a_i b)=b^{-1}a_i b\in A'$, we see that $b\rho(b)^{-1}\in Z(a_i)$. But since the $a_i$ are linearly independent, we see that $b \rho(b)^{-1}\in Z(A')=Z(SL(n,k))$ since $A'$ is Zariski dense. Thus, we see that there are only finitely many possibilities for $\rho(b)$ for each $b$, and therefore the variety $X$ is finite. This in turn implies that $k'$ is a finite extension of $k$, since a transcendental extension would give rise to a variety $X$ of dimension $\geq 1$, since you could vary the transcendental generators at will.

Addendum: One may actually show that $k'$ is a Galois extension of $k$. Since $Z(SL(n,\mathbb{C}))=\{ \zeta I: \zeta^n=1\}$, we see that $\rho(b)=\zeta b$, for some $\zeta \in k', \zeta^n=1$. Thus, for different Galois embeddings $\sigma:k'\to \mathbb{C}$ which restrict to the identity on $k$, the entries of $\sigma(b)$ will change by multiplication by a cyclotomic number. So we conclude $b_{ij}^n \in k$ for each matrix entry $b_{ij}$ of $b$. This implies that $k'$ is a Galois extension of $k$ obtained by adding finitely many $n$-th roots to $k$.

share|cite|improve this answer
Nice argument. Note that "discrete" is not used, so everything is entirely algebraic. I think the key point is this: Let $G$ be an algebraic group over a field $k$, $\Omega$ an alg. closed extension of $k$. Assume $A\vartriangleleft B$ are subgroups of $G(\Omega)$ with $A\subset G(k)$, and that $A$ has finite centralizer in $G$ (e.g. $A$ is Zariski-dense and $G$ has finite center). Then $B\subset G(\overline{k})$. Proof: if $b\in B$ and $\rho$ is a $k$-automorphism of $\Omega$, then Agol's computation shows that $\rho(b)b^{-1}$ centralizes $A$, hence the "Galois" orbit of $b$ is finite. – Laurent Moret-Bailly Oct 8 '10 at 11:45

Agol's argument is really nice. For what it is worth, I would like to add a few comments. Suppose we assume that $G$ is absolutely simple (in particular, $G$ is centreless). Then Agol's argument shows that $k'=k$. Secondly, one can replace $G$ by a conjugate in its adjoint representation and assume that the smaller Zariski dense subgroup $A$ is contained in $G(k_0)$ where $k_0$ is the "smallest possible field", namely the field generated by the traces of elements of $A$ in the adjoint representation. All these are proved in an old paper of Vinberg.

share|cite|improve this answer

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.