Let FinCar denote the category whose objects are the finite cardinal numbers $[n]=\{0,\dots, n\}$ and whose morphisms are all functions between them, and let $X$ be a a contravariant functor from FinCar into Ab, the category of Abelian groups. The morphisms of FinCar are generated by the co-face and co-degeneracy maps of the subcategory FinOrd of finite ordinals and monotonic maps, together with the symmetric group $S_{n+1}$ which is a subset of $Hom([n],[n])$ for each $n$. Therefore, $X$ can be regarded as a simplicial Abelian group together with an action of $S_{n+1}$ on $X_n$ for each $n$.

I define the group $X'_n$ to be the subgroup of $X_n$ which is invariant/fixed under the action of $S_{n+1}$. I notice that each face map $d_i$ carries $X_n'$ into $X_{n-1}'$; so I can regard $X'$ as a semi-simplicial Abelian group; I don't think $X'$ is a simplicial Abelian group as I can't figure out what the degeneracies would be.

In any case by taking alternating sums of face maps both $X,X'$ become chain complexes. Do they have the same homology? Is the inclusion map a quasi-isomorphism?

I have some basic competency with spectral sequences if this helps.


1 Answer 1


No. Let $X$ be the functor that takes $[n]$ to the group of maps $[n]\to \mathbb Z$. Then $H_0X=0$ while $H_0X'\cong\mathbb Z$.


You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .