For any groups $G,H$, we can define the category, in fact a groupoid, $$\underline{\text{Hom}}(G,H)$$ whose objects are group morphisms $G\to H$ and morphisms $(f:G\to H)\to (g:G\to H)$ are elements of $H$ conjugating $f$ into $g$. Let $\{H_i\}_{i\in I}$ be an inverse system of groups. Then of course we have $\text{Hom}(G,\lim_{i\in I} H_i)\cong \lim_{i\in I}\text{Hom}(G, H_i)$. My question is do we also have $$\underline{\text{Hom}}(G,\lim_{i\in I} H_i)\cong \lim_{i\in I}\underline{\text{Hom}}(G, H_i)?$$


Sure, this follows from the Yoneda lemma. Let $B : \text{Grp} \to \text{Grpd}$ be the functor sending any group $G$ to the groupoid with one element $\star$ such that $BG(\star, \star) = G$. For any groupoid $X$ we have \begin{align} \text{Grpd}(X, \underline{\text{Hom}}(G,\lim_{i\in I} H_i)) &\cong \text{Grpd}(X, \underline{\text{Grpd}}(BG, B\lim_{i\in I} H_i)) \\&\cong \text{Grpd}(X \times BG, B\lim_{i\in I} H_i) \\&\cong \lim_{i \in I}\text{Grpd}(X \times BG, BH_i) \\&\cong \lim_{i \in I}\text{Grpd}(X, \underline{\text{Grpd}}(BG, BH_i)) \\&\cong \lim_{i \in I}\text{Grpd}(X, \underline{\text{Hom}}(G, H_i)) \\&\cong \text{Grpd}(X, \lim_{i \in I}\underline{\text{Hom}}(G, H_i)) \end{align} using the universal property of the internal hom and the continuity of $B$ and the Yoneda embedding. So by the fully-faithfulness of the Yoneda embedding we have the isomorphism in your question.

To show that $B$ preserves limits it's not too hard to show directly that it preserves products and equalizers. But it also preserves limits because it's a right adjoint. Its left adjoint can be constructed as follows. Let $\text{Grpd}_{1}$ be the full subcategory of $\text{Grpd}$ on the one-element groupoids. Then $B : \text{Grp} \to \text{Grpd}_{1}$ is an equivalence, so it suffices to give a left adjoint to the inclusion $\text{Grpd}_{1} \to \text{Grpd}$, which I'll also abusively call $B$.

For any groupoid $X$, let $X^{\delta}$ be the discrete groupoid on the underlying set of $X$, and let $i_{X} : X^{\delta} \to X$ be the canonical inclusion. The pushout of $i_{X}$ along the unique functor $X^{\delta} \to *$ gives a one-element groupoid $LX$ (it's not hard to show that this has one element, using the fact that the underlying set functor $\text{Grpd} \to \text{Set}$ is a left adjoint). For any one-element groupoid $G$ we therefore have \begin{align} \text{Grpd}_{1}(LX, G) &= \text{Grpd}(LX, G) \\&\cong \text{Grpd}(*, BG) \times_{\text{Grpd}(X^{\delta}, BG)} \text{Grpd}(X, BG) \\&\cong \text{Grpd}(X, BG) \end{align} by the definition of $\text{Grpd}_{1}$, the universal property of $LX$, and the isomorphism $\text{Grpd}(X^{\delta}, BG) \cong * \cong \text{Grpd}(*, BG)$.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Oh, I didn't know that this construction was the internal Hom in the category of groupoids, thanks! Do you have a reference for the fact that functor (Groups) $\to$ (Groupoids) is continuous? $\endgroup$ Dec 7 '20 at 12:47
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ @curiousmathguy unfortunately I don't, but I will add an argument for it. good call, though, especially since it's not cocontinuous, so I shouldn't have elided the inclusion. $\endgroup$ Dec 7 '20 at 14:23
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ In your last proof, it should be a $\times$, not a $\sqcup$ $\endgroup$ Dec 7 '20 at 18:41
  • $\begingroup$ @MaximeRamzi oops, you're quite right, thanks $\endgroup$ Dec 7 '20 at 18:48
  • $\begingroup$ No problem, nice answer ! $\endgroup$ Dec 7 '20 at 19:33

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.