If $M$ and $N$ are closed smooth manifolds, and $M\times S^1$ is diffeomorphic to $N\times S^1$, is it true that $M$ and $N$ are diffeomorphic?

  • $\begingroup$ This has to be in the literature somewhere... Internet suggests it's true for simply-connected n-manifolds with n > 4. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:02
  • $\begingroup$ Definitely not true if M is of dim 4. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:04
  • $\begingroup$ @ Chris: I am sure it is. I don't know where to find it. I googled but did not find anything. I asked our topologists; no response yet. The one with S^2 instead of S^1 is (negative) pretty famous and important. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:04
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @IgorBelegradek: Sorry, I didn't see your comment when I posted my answer which is effectively your first sentence. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 14:04
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @MichaelAlbanese: no worries. I was too lazy to post an answer, and it is good that you did that, since the answers get more visibility. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 16:00

2 Answers 2


If $M$ is of dimension $<4$ then the answer is YES because there are no exotic structures on $M$ and there are full classification results.[EDIT: In case of 3-manifolds this is true except some surface bundles over $S^1$ with fiber genus $>1$ and periodic monodromy, Stability of 3-manifolds.]

It is not true in dimension 4. For example, any closed simply-connected 4-manifold $M$ and an exotic copy $M'$ are h-cobordant by a theorem of Wall. Thus $M\times S^1$ is h-cobordant to $M'\times S^1$ (as one can extend the previus h-cobordsim trivially on the $S^1$ component). This is then a trivial cobordism by the high-dimensional s-cobordism theorem which says that such an h-cobordism is trivial if the Whitehead torsion of $\pi_1(M\times S^1)$ vanishes and indeed $Wh(\pi_1(M\times S^1))= Wh(\mathbb Z)=0$ by a result of Bass. So they are in fact diffeomorphic.

When the dimension is $>4$ the answer is YES if $M$ is simply-connected. To see this, notice that it is enough to show that $M$ and $M'$ are h-cobordant. Since $M\times S^1$ is diffeomorphic to $M'\times S^1$ there is a map $f:M \to M'\times S^1$. Since $M$ is simply-connected $f$ has a lift $\bar{f}$ to the universal cover $M'\times \mathbb R$. We claim that the image of $\bar{f}$ separates $M'\times \mathbb R$. Otherwise we can cut $M'\times \mathbb R$ along $Im(\bar{f})$ and connect the two boundary components by an arc $\gamma$. This arc in the original manifold $M'\times \mathbb R$ gives rise to a closed curve $\gamma'$ which transversally intersects $Im(\bar{f})$ at a single point. But $M'\times \mathbb R$ is simply-connected and thus $\gamma'$ is homotopic to a point disjoint from $Im(\bar{f})$, contradicting the homotopy-invariant count of transverse intersection points. Now, since $M$ is compact we can find a cobordism from $Im(\bar{f})\approx M$ to $M'\times \{t\}$ for some sufficiently large $t\in \mathbb R$. Since everything is simply-connected and the projection map induces isomorphisms on homologies, by Hurewitz' theorem we can conclude that this is an h-cobordism and so $M$ is diffeomorphic to $M'$.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks, that was quick, though I am not familiar with some of the content. Probably you can expand the second and third sentences of your answer a little bit. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:17
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @MohammadFarajzadeh-Tehrani I tried to add a few references. Please let me know if it is helpful or not. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:38
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ very good. thanks $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 3:39
  • $\begingroup$ @MohammadFarajzadeh-Tehrani I made a few changes in my ans. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 4:06
  • $\begingroup$ Sorry if I am being daft, but why is the image of $\bar{f}$ separating? $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 15:34

The manifolds $M$ and $N$ may not even be homotopy equivalent!

In Compact Flat Riemannian Manifolds: I, Charlap showed that there are two closed flat manifolds $M$ and $N$ of the same dimension which are not homotopy equivalent (this is equivalent to $\pi_1(M) \not\cong \pi_1(N)$ as $M$ and $N$ are aspherical), such that $M\times S^1$ and $N\times S^1$ are diffeomorphic (which is equivalent to $\pi_1(M\times S^1) \cong \pi_1(N\times S^1)$ as closed flat manifolds are determined up to diffeomorphism by their fundamental group).

For a more explicit example, see this excellent answer by George Lowther.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks for the answer. I was thinking about that too. In your response, $M$ and $N$ are compact but not closed, correct? $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 13:26
  • $\begingroup$ They are closed, I will edit to make this clear. $\endgroup$ Jun 25, 2020 at 13:50

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.