9
$\begingroup$

It is well known that the automorphism group of the alternating group $A_6$ is $P\Gamma L_2(9)$. There are three different index $2$ subgroups of $P\Gamma L_2(9)$, namely the symmetric group $S_6$, the projective general linear group $PGL_2(9)$, and the Mathieu group $M_{10}$. By checking the ATLAS (http://brauer.maths.qmul.ac.uk/Atlas/v3/), the Schur multipliers of those groups $A_6,S_6, PGL_2(9)$ are the cyclic group $Z_6$. What about the Mathieu group $M_{10}$?

Also, I don't know why, in the following book, Page 302, Table 4.1, the Schur multiplier of the group ${\sf C}_2(2)$ is listed to be the cyclic group $Z_2$?

Gorenstein, Daniel, Finite simple groups. An introduction to their classification, Moskva: Mir. 352 p. R. 2.50 (1985). ZBL0672.20010.

$\endgroup$
1

1 Answer 1

10
$\begingroup$

$H_2(M_{10},\mathbb Z)\cong H^2(M_{10},\mathbb C^\times)\cong H^3(M_{10},\mathbb Z) = \oplus_{ p | 720} H^3(M_{10},\mathbb Z)_{(p)}$ with $p\in\lbrace 2,3,5\rbrace$. A $p$-primary component is isomorphic to the set of $M_{10}$-invariant elements of $H^3(\text{Syl}_p(M_{10}))$. We can check that $M_{10}$ has semi-dihedral Sylow 2-subgroups and cyclic Sylow 5-subgroups (Wikipedia), both of whose Schur multiplier is trivial. So we're left with the 3-primary component. We can check that $M_{10}$ has elementary abelian Sylow 3-subgroups (Wikipedia), all isomorphic to $\mathbb Z_3^2$, and thus $H^3(M_{10})_{(3)}\cong H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)^{H/\mathbb Z^2_3}$ by Swan's theorem, where $H$ is the normalizer of $\mathbb Z_3^2\subset M_{10}$. This invariant subgroup is the full group $H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)\cong\mathbb Z_3$ (see below), so $H_2(M_{10},\mathbb Z)\cong\mathbb Z_3$.

To see that $H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)^{H/\mathbb Z_3^2}\cong H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)$, we first note that our $H$ is a maximal subgroup of order 72 so we may as well take it to be the Mathieu group $M_9=\mathbb Z_3^2\rtimes Q_8$ sitting naturally inside $M_{10}$, where $Q_8$ acts as the faithful two-dimensional irreducible representation over $\mathbb Z_3$. So we need to check that $H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)^{Q_8}\cong H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)$. For the standard generators $\{I,J\}$ of $Q_8$ and basis $\{a,b\}$ of $\mathbb Z_3^2$ we have $I(a)=a+b$, $I(b)= a-b$, $J(a)=-a+b$, and $J(b)=a+b$. Noting that $H^\ast(\mathbb Z_3^2,\mathbb Z_3) = \mathbb Z_3[x,y]\otimes\Lambda(u,v)$ with $|x|=|y|=2$ and $|u|=|v|=1$, the element $uv$ is $Q_8$-invariant. The induced map $\delta:H^2(\mathbb Z_3^2,\mathbb Z_3)\to H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2,\mathbb Z)$ under the short exact sequence $\mathbb Z\hookrightarrow\mathbb Z\twoheadrightarrow\mathbb Z_3$ is surjective and $Q_8$-equivariant, with image $\langle\delta(uv)\rangle$, and so $H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)^{Q_8}\cong H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)$.

We've essentially shown that this agrees with the Schur multiplier of $M_9$ by the same technique (note that the Schur multiplier of $Q_8$ is trivial), $H_2(M_9)\cong H^3(\mathbb Z_3^2)^{Q_8}\cong\mathbb Z_3$.

$\endgroup$
1
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Yes that's right. Note that the $3$-part of the Schur Multipliers of the two other extensions $S_6$ and ${\rm PGL}(2,9)$ of $A_6$ by groups of order $2$ are both trivial, because the outer involutions in those two groups invert the central $C_3$ subgroup. So it is centralized by their product, which is the outer element of $M_{10}$. $\endgroup$
    – Derek Holt
    Jun 3, 2020 at 18:37

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.