Let $R$ be the hyperfinite $II_1$ factor, and let $G$ be a locally compact group.

(1) Does there always exist a continuous, (faithful) outer action of $G$ on $R$?
(2) If so, how does one construct one?
(3) Is there any hope of classifying such actions?

(1) Here, an "action" is a continuous homomorphism $\rho:G \to Aut(R)$, where the latter is equipped with the $u$-topology, i.e., the topology of pointwise convergence on the predual $R_*$. Such an action is called "outer" if $\rho(G)\cap Inn(R)=\{\mathrm{id}_R\}$.

(2) Note that for $G$ discrete, one can do a "Bernoulli shift" action on $\bigotimes_G M_2(\mathbb C)$. Is there a continuous analog of the above construction?

(3) In his PhD thesis, Vaughan Jones provided a complete answer to that question when $G$ is finite. Injective homomorphisms $\bar \rho:G\to Out(R)$ are classified, up to conjugation in $Out(R)$, by a cohomology class $\omega_{\bar \rho}\in H^3(G,U(1))$. And $\bar\rho$ comes from a homomorphism $\rho:G\to Aut(R)$ iff $\omega_{\bar \rho}=0$. It is perhaps reasonable to expect this result to extend to all ameanable groups. Has this question been investigated?

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I thought the discrete amenable case of (3) was done by Ocneanu?! $\endgroup$ – Marcel Bischoff Mar 10 '19 at 2:29
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @Marcel Bischoff: Is this written up? Where can I read about it? $\endgroup$ – André Henriques Mar 10 '19 at 11:53
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ If $G$ is totally disconnected, then it has a faithful continuous action on a discrete set $X$ (which can be chosen countable if $G$ is second-countable). What do you think of the Bernoulli-link action on $\bigotimes_{X}M_2(\mathbf{C})$? $\endgroup$ – YCor Mar 10 '19 at 12:02
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I was referring to springer.com/us/book/9783540156635 but I don't remember what the actual result was and don't have access right now. I only remember that it generalizes certain results of Jones. Reading Robin's answer it might not be relevant to your question as I thought. $\endgroup$ – Marcel Bischoff Mar 10 '19 at 20:01

The answer to (1) (for second countable groups) is yes: every locally compact second countable group $G$ admits a countinuous, faithful outer action on the hyperfinite $II_1$ factor. This is attributed to Blattner, and is stated explicitly in Proposition 1 of the following article:

R. J. Plymen. "Automorphic group representations: The hyperfinite $II_1$ factor and the Weyl algebra." Algèbres d’Opérateurs. Springer, Berlin, Heidelberg, 1979. 291-306.

The action is obtained as the Bogoliubov action associated to the direct sum of countably many copies of the left regular representation of $G$ on $L^2(G)$.

Question (3) has been addressed by Kerr, Li, and Pichot in

David Kerr, Hanfeng Li, and Mikaël Pichot. "Turbulence, representations, and trace-preserving actions." Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society 100.2 (2009): 459-484.

They show that there is no hope of classifying all such actions, up to isomorphism, in general. They make this precise by using the language of Borel equivalence relations and Hjorth's theory of turbulence.

I refer you to their paper for the precise statements and a detailed discussion of what all this entails, but here is one of their results: they show that for every countably infinite amenable group $G$, the equivalence relation of isomorphism of free actions of $G$ on $R$ is not classifiable by countable structures, i.e., there is no Baire measurable way of using (isomorphism classes of) countable structures (e.g., countable groups, countable rings) as complete invariants for isomorphism classes of these actions. In fact, what they show is even stronger than this: in the Polish space of all free actions of $G$ on $R$, every isomorphism class is meager, and every isomorphism-invariant Baire measurable assignment of (isomorphism classes of) countable structures to these actions is actually constant on a comeager set of actions.

${\bf \text{Update:}}$ My original answer to (3) above addresses the possibility of classifying actions of $G$ on $R$ up to isomorphism, instead of up to outer conjugacy. As Marcel Bischoff indicated in the comments, Oceanu studied the question of classifying actions of a discrete amenable group $G$ on $R$ up to outer conjugacy in

Ocneanu, Adrian. Actions of discrete amenable groups on von Neumann algebras. Vol. 1138. Springer, 2006.

Ocneanu proves is that any two free actions of a discrete amenable group $G$ on $R$ are outer conjugate. As Ocneanu points out, the assumption that $G$ is amenable is necessary, as shown by Jones in

Jones, Vaughan F.R. "A converse to Ocneanu's theorem." Journal of Operator Theory (1983): 61-63.


A positive answer to my question (2) is provided in the last section of Popa Takesaki "Topological structure of unitary and automorphism groups".

They show that for any locally compact group $G$, the action of $G$ on the $II_1$ factor $\{\mathit{CAR}(L^2G)\}''$ is appropriately continuous. Here, the double commutant is taken on $L^2(\mathit{CAR}(L^2G),tr)$ with respect to the unique trace on $\mathit{CAR}(L^2G)$, and $\mathit{CAR}$ is the algebra of canonical anticommutation relations (a.k.a. Clifford algebra).

Answer courtesy of Daniel Bruegmann.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.