Let $f$ be a newform of weight $k \geq 2$ and level $N \geq 1$ without complex multiplication. A prime $p$ is said to be ordinary for $f$ if the $p$-th Fourier coefficient $a_p(f)$ is a $p$-adic unit (to make sense of this in general, one needs to choose a prime ideal above $p$ in the field $K_f$ of Fourier coefficients of $f$, equivalently an embedding of $K_f$ into $\overline{\mathbf{Q}_p}$).

Non-ordinary primes seem to be rare. For example, if $f$ has coefficients in $\mathbf{Z}$, then a very rough guess is that $a_p(f)$ modulo $p$ is randomly distributed, so we may expect that

\begin{equation*} \# \{p \leq x : a_p \equiv 0 \textrm{ mod } p \} \stackrel{?}{\approx} \sum_{p \leq x} \frac{1}{p} \sim \log \log x. \end{equation*} On the other hand, for the modular form $\Delta = \sum_{n \geq 1} \tau(n) q^n$, it seems not to be known that there are infinitely many primes $p$ such that $\tau(p) \not\equiv 0$ mod $p$, so estimating the number of ordinary or non-ordinary primes is difficult in general.

If we consider elliptic curves, we may ask whether every prime $p$ is non-ordinary for some elliptic curve $E$ over $ \mathbf{ Q } $, which means that the reduction of $E$ mod $p$ is supersingular. In fact, Deuring has shown that given any integer $a$ such that $|a|<2\sqrt{p}$, there exists an elliptic curve $E_p$ over the finite field $\mathbf{F}_p$ with exactly $p+1-a$ points over $\mathbf{F}_p$. Now take any elliptic curve $E$ over $\mathbf{Q}$ whose reduction mod $p$ is $E_p$ and use the modularity theorem. We get a modular form $f$ of weight $2$ with integral coefficients satisfying $a_p(f)=a$, and we may choose it to be non-CM (in fact, we get infinitely many such modular forms).

My question is whether this kind of result is known or even expected in higher weight. Certainly, if you have a finite set of newforms without CM, the above heuristics suggest that there exist infinitely many primes which are ordinary for all these newforms. But I don't know what happens for an infinite set of newforms, even if this set is "thin" in some sense.

Here is another example of question which arises.

Fix a weight $k \geq 3$. Is every prime $p$ non-ordinary for some non-CM newform of weight $k$ and level not dividing $p$? At least, are there infinitely many such primes?

Hida's theory implies that if $p \geq 5$ and $k$ is equal to $\{3,4,5,\ldots,10,14\}$ modulo $p-1$, then all newforms of weight $k$ and level $1$ are non-ordinary at $p$. This gives a positive answer to the question for some primes $p$ which are small with respect to $k$ (in particular, these primes satisfy $p \leq k-2$).

One may try to use the theory of congruences between modular forms, like the theory of Hida families, but usually one starts with a modular form which is ordinary at $p$, and I don't know to which extent the theory has been generalized to the non-ordinary case.


Given p and k, it's clear we can find a CM-type newform of weight k and some level which is supersingular at p (just choose an imaginary quadratic field in which p is inert, and some sufficiently large conductor away from p).

So it suffices to find a second newform that is congruent to the first one mod p and is not of CM type. This can always be done (after adding some auxiliary primes to the level) by the answer to this old question of mine: Congruences between CM and non-CM modular forms.

  • $\begingroup$ Very nice and helpful answer, thank you! $\endgroup$ – François Brunault Sep 10 '18 at 20:58
  • $\begingroup$ Of course, this leads immediately to a much harder question: can one always find an $f$ satisfying the conditions of your question such that the mod p Galois representation of f has large image? $\endgroup$ – David Loeffler Sep 11 '18 at 13:17

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.