For a univariate distribution or a univariate random variable, we call it continuous/absolutely continuous if its cumulative distribution function (CDF) is continuous/absolutely continuous. Now I am trying to extend this concept to the multivariate case, and want the following holds: The continuity of a random vector does not change under homeomorphisms.

If we still define the continuity of a distribution only according to the continuity of its CDF, then the invariance property above does not hold. This can be seen from the following example.

For any random vector $(X,X)$ where $X$ is continuous, it is easy to check that this vector is continuous (according to the definition above). We transform $(X,X)$ into $(2X,0)$ by the homeomorphism $(x,y)\mapsto (x+y,x-y)$. Obviously, $(2X,0)$ is not continuous.

Now I give two new definitions of the continuity of a random vector.

(Definition 1) For random vector $(X,Y)$, we call it continuous if $F_{X'Y'}(x,y)$ is jointly continuous in $(x,y)$ for any homeomorphism $(X,Y)\mapsto (X',Y')$. Here $F_{X'Y'}$ is the CDF of $(X',Y')$.

(Definition 2) For random vector $(X,Y)$, we call it continuous if $F_X(x)$ is continuous, and $F_{Y|X}(y|x)$ is continuous in $y$ for $P_X$-almost every $x$. Here $F_X$ and $F_{Y|X}$ are the CDF of $X$ and the conditional CDF of $Y$ given $X$, and $P_X$ is the distribution of $X$.

My question is: For Definition 2, does the continuity of a random vector change under homeomorphisms? If yes, for any continuous random vector $(X,Y)$, is $(Y,X)$ also continuous?


1 Answer 1

  1. I believe the term continuous distribution (or a continuous measure) is often used to refer to a distribution without atoms.

  2. Homeomorphisms of $\mathbb{R}^2$ can be very singular. For example, there is a homeomorphism $\Phi$ that maps the vertical interval $\{(0, y) : y \in [0, 1]\}$ into the Osgood curve. If $(X,Y)$ has a uniform distribution on a square that contains this Osgood curve and $$(X',Y') = \Phi^{-1}(X,Y),$$ then $X'$ has an atom at zero.

  3. For the above reason, any definition of a continuous distribution in $\mathbb{R}^2$ which is invariant under homeomorphisms must include distributions with discontinuous marginals. In particular, your Definition 1 is void, and the answer to your first question about Definition 2 is: yes, it may change.

  4. If $(X,Y)$ satisfies your Definition 2, then clearly $Y$ is a continuous random variable: $$\mathbb{P}(Y = y) = \int \mathbb{P}(Y = y | X = x) P_X(dx) = 0.$$ However, $(Y,X)$ may fail to satisfy Definition 2, a counterexample is given below. In other words, the answer to your second question about Definition 2 is: no.

  5. Take $X,Z$ to be two independent random variables uniformly concentrated on a Cantor set $$C = \left\{\sum_{n = 1}^\infty \frac{a_n}{5^n} : a_n \in \{0,1\}\right\},$$ and define $Y = X + 2 Z$. Then $X$ has a continuous distribution, and for every $x \in C$, $Y$ has a continuous conditional distribution $x + 2 Z$ given $X = x$. On the other hand, for every $y \in [0, 1)$ there is at most one pair $(x, z) \in C \times C$ such $y = x + 2 z$, and therefore the conditional distribution of $X$ given $Y = y$ is always a Dirac delta.

  • $\begingroup$ Thank you for your answer! Could you provide a reference that involves "continuous measures"? I only found that a distribution/measure without atoms is called a atomless or non-atomic distribution/measure. It is called a continuous distribution only for univariate cases. $\endgroup$
    – Leon
    Jul 22, 2018 at 14:46
  • $\begingroup$ BTW, I was going to construct a distribution like yours in 5. Thank you for providing it to me first! $\endgroup$
    – Leon
    Jul 22, 2018 at 14:51
  • $\begingroup$ @LeiYu: You're welcome. I had the feeling that atomless', non-atomic' and `continuous' are synonyms here (a quick Google search yields several examples, like this, this, this or this, but indeed this may be too strong a statement; I'll edit the answer in a minute. $\endgroup$ Jul 22, 2018 at 15:41

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.