We work in a separable metric space $(X,d)$. With $\overline{B}(x,r)$ I denote the closed ball around $x$ of radius $r$, and with $cl \ B(x,r)$ I denote the closure of the open ball. Clearly, we always have $cl \ B(x,r) \subseteq \overline{B}(x,r)$, and it is easy to construct examples where the inclusion is strict.

Question: Can we have this locally everywhere, meaning does there exists a separable metric space $(X,d)$, a point $x \in X$ and a real $R$ such that for all $r$ with $R > r > 0$ we find that $cl \ B(x,r) \subsetneq \overline{B}(x,r)$ ?

My naive attempt to construct this by brute-force violates the separability criterion. I am tempted to believe that we can have the difference only for countably many radii, but so far I was not able to prove this.

Restrictions on $(X,d)$ I'd be willing to accept (and that I would particularly enjoy in a positive example) are completeness and local compactness.

This question here is related, it is asking about spaces where $cl \ B(x,r) = \overline{B}(x,r)$ holds always.


The following theorem (or its corollary) implies negative answer to the original question.

Theorem. For any point $x$ of a metric space $(X,d)$ the set $R_x:=\{r>0:cl(B(x,r))\ne \bar B(x,r)\}$ has cardinality $|R_x|\le w(X)$, where $w(X)$ stands for the weight of the topology of the metric space $(X,d)$.

Proof. Fix a base $\mathcal W$ of the topology of the space $X$ of cardinality $|\mathcal W|=w(X)$. For every $r\in R_x$ choose a point $x_r\in\bar B(x,r)\setminus cl(B(x,r))$ and find a basic neighborhood $W_r\in\mathcal W$ of $x_r$, which is disjoint with the open ball $B(x,r)$. Assuming that $|R_x|>w(X)=|\mathcal W|$, we can find two distinct real numbers $r<\rho$ in $R_x$ such that $W_r=W_\rho$. Then $x_r\in W_r=W_\rho$ and $x_r\in \bar B(x,r)\subset B(x,\rho)$. So, $x_r\in W_\rho\cap B(x,\rho)=\emptyset$, which is a desired contradiction showing that $|R_x|\le w(X)$.

Corollary. For any point $x$ of a locally compact (more generally, locally separable) metric space $(X,d)$ there exists $\varepsilon>0$ such that the set $\{r\in(0,\varepsilon):cl(B(x,r))\ne\bar B(x,r)\}$ is at most countable.

  • $\begingroup$ @tomasz Every locally compact metrizable space is locally separable (the problem essentially concerns metric spaces). $\endgroup$ – Taras Banakh Jun 29 '18 at 5:44
  • $\begingroup$ Right. Of course. I thought by "more generally" you meant that it is more general in general. ;) $\endgroup$ – tomasz Jun 29 '18 at 11:12

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.