I'm trying to close in on a definitive answer to my own question BVPs for elliptic PDOs: When do Green functions ($L^2$ inverses) define pseudo-differential operators in the interior?, and think I have reduced it to the following subproblem about the interplay between smoothing operators and (bounded) $L^2$ operators preserving smoothness (see below) on a Riemannian manifold.

Setup/notation: Let $(M,g)$ be a smooth Riemannian manifold, not necessarily compact or complete, and let $\mathrm{d} \mu_g$ be the smooth measure on $M$ determined by the volume density of $g$. Let $L^2(M,\mathrm{d} \mu_g)$ be the resulting Hilbert space of functions on $M$ which are square-integrable with respect to $\mathrm{d} \mu_g$. Let $G : L^2(M,\mathrm{d} \mu_g) \to L^2(M,\mathrm{d} \mu_g)$ be a bounded linear operator with the property that $G[C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)] \subseteq C^\infty(M)$—if necessary for the proof, I'm happy to also assume that $G[H^{s}_\mathrm{c}(M)] \subseteq H^{s+k}_\mathrm{loc}(M)$ for all real $s \geq 0$ and some fixed $k > 0$, where $H^{s}_\mathrm{c}(M)$ and $H^{t}_\mathrm{loc}(M)$ are the standard spaces of compactly supported Sobolev distributions and of locally Sobolev distributions on $M$, respectively. In the latter case, however, I am not willing to assume from the outset that the resulting maps $H^{s}_\mathrm{c}(M) \to H^{s+k}_\mathrm{loc}(M)$ are continuous in the standard topologies of these Sobolev spaces. Let also $\mathscr{D}'(M)$ denote the standard space of distributions on $M$, and $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ the space of distributions with compact support. A smoothing operator is a continuous operator $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M) \to \mathscr{D}'(M)$ whose Schwartz kernel is an element of $C^\infty(M \times M)$.

Question: If $R$ is a properly supported smoothing operator [so that $R$ sends $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ to $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$], does it follow that the composition $GR$ defines a smoothing operator?

My understanding:

  1. By my assumption on $G$, $GR$ is well-defined as a linear map from $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ to $C^\infty(M)$. This is a purely algebraic statement.
  2. An immediate analytic prerequisite is that the related linear map $\widetilde{GR} : C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M) \to \mathscr{D}'(M)$, given by postcomposing with the obvious embedding, should be continuous when $\mathscr{D}'(M)$ has the standard weak topology. But this is the case because properly supported operators are continuous from $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$ to $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$, while $L^2$-bounded ones such as $G$ define continuous maps from $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$ to $\mathscr{D}'(M)$.
  3. As far as I know, even when taken together the statements in 1. and 2. do not automatically ensure that we are dealing with a smoothing operator proper. According to this note, we also need to know that $GR:\mathscr{E}'(M) \to C^\infty(M)$ is sequentially continuous when $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ has the weak topology and $C^\infty(M)$ has the standard Fréchet space topology. Alternatively, there is the following characterization of smoothing operators which I am adapting from Dieudonné's Treatise on Analysis, Vol. 7, (23.11.1) (and see also a similar statement in Hörmander's The Analysis of Linear Partial Differential Operators I, Theorem 5.2.6):

    Let $K$ be a linear map from $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ to the Fréchet space $C^\infty(M)$ which is continuous on all bounded subsets of $\mathscr{E}'(M)$. Then $K$ is the extension to $\mathscr{E}'(M)$ of a smoothing integral operator.

Under my minimal assumptions on $G$ I am not sure how to establish that either of the continuity conditions in 3. is satisfied.

  • $\begingroup$ This is the connection with my original MO question: there, $G$ is a Green function for an elliptic differential operator $P$. $P$ admits a pair of properly supported pseudo-differential operators $Q, R$, with $R$ smoothing, such that $PQ = I + R$. Then, when both sides are restricted to $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$, we can left-compose with $G$ to get $G = Q - GR$, and in order to establish the pseudo-differential property of $G$ it suffices to establish that $GR$ is a smoothing operator. $\endgroup$
    – JahvedM
    Nov 28 '17 at 17:34
  • $\begingroup$ I'm a bit puzzled, because the note that you reference gives this equivalent criterion for being smoothing: that we have such an extension $GR: \mathcal{E}^\prime(M)\rightarrow C^\infty(M)$. But its proof also requires the hypothesis that $M$ be a closed manifold, hence both compact and complete! I don't have access to Dieudonne's text, but you should check whether he requires this condition as well. $\endgroup$ Nov 29 '17 at 1:07
  • $\begingroup$ Since everything here is local, I doubt that the assumption of compactness is really needed. $\endgroup$
    – Deane Yang
    Nov 29 '17 at 4:16
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Don't we have a continuous inclusion $L^2\hookrightarrow \mathscr D'$? Then $G$ is a continuous map $L^2 \to \mathscr D'$ so that its restriction $C_c^\infty \to C^\infty$ has closed graph and is thus continuous (where $C_c^\infty$ is endowed with its inductive limit topology). $\endgroup$ Nov 29 '17 at 13:49
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ The closed graph theorem applies to linear maps from LF-spaces to Frechet spaces and continuity with respect to coarser Hausdorff topologies implies closed graph. $\endgroup$ Nov 29 '17 at 15:33

Thanks to Jochen Wengenroth's comments, I can now give the full answer: the idea is that $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M) \hookrightarrow L^2(M, \mathrm{d} \mu_g) \xrightarrow{G} L^2(M, \mathrm{d} \mu_g) \hookrightarrow \mathscr{D}'(M)$ is continuous, and an argument using a version of the closed graph theorem in the (locally) Fréchet category then shows that simply by virtue of mapping $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$ to $C^\infty(M)$, $G$ must actually do so continuously with respect to the Fréchet topology of $C^\infty(M)$. In detail:

Lemma. Let $T:C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M) \to \mathscr{D}'(M)$ be linear, continuous relative to the standard inductive limit topology of $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$ and the weak topology of $\mathscr{D}'(M)$, and with image contained in $C^\infty(M)$. Then $T:C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)\to C^\infty(M)$ is continuous relative to the standard Fréchet space topology of the codomain.

Proof. $T$ is continuous as a map $C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)\to C^\infty(M)$ when the codomain is equipped with the subspace topology from $\mathscr{D}'(M)$. Hence its graph is closed in the appropriate product topology, and it is also closed in the finer product topology obtained by equipping $C^\infty(M)$ with its Fréchet space topology. The result then follows from the fact that the closed graph theorem is applicable to linear maps from LF-spaces to Fréchet spaces.

Wrapping up. Since $R : \mathscr{E}'(M) \to C_\mathrm{c}^\infty(M)$ is continuous, so is the composition $GR : \mathscr{E}'(M) \to C^\infty(M)$. By the equivalence criteria I mentioned in the question, this implies the smoothing property.

Thanks to all who helped with this.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.