I am not sure that this is a research level question. Remark 10.9.4 in the book "A course in metric geometry" by Burago, Burago, Ivanov claims the following.

Let $X$ be a finite dimensional Alexandrov space with curvature bounded below. Fix $p\in X$ and $\varepsilon> 0$. Then there exists $r>0$ such that for any two points $x,y$ such that $|px|,|py|<r$ one has $$|\tilde\measuredangle xpy -\measuredangle xpy|<\varepsilon.$$

I would be happy to have a detailed proof of this result or a reference to it.

Thank you.


Partly following the advise in Anton Petrunin's answer, let me present a proof in greater detail.

We prove the statement in the case of non-negative curvature. Assume the contrary. Then there exist $\delta >0$ and sequences $x_n,y_n\to p$ such that $0<|px_n|\leq |py_n|\to 0$, and \begin{eqnarray}\label{0} \tilde\measuredangle x_npy_n< \measuredangle x_npy_n-\delta. \end{eqnarray} We denote for brevity $$r_n:=|px_n|,\, R_n:=|py_n|,\, \alpha_n:=\measuredangle x_npy_n, \tilde\alpha:=\tilde\measuredangle x_npy_n.$$ Thus $$r_n\leq R_n\to 0,\, \tilde\alpha_n<\alpha_n-\delta.$$

Choosing a subsequence, we may assume that there exists a geodesic $\gamma$ starting at $p$ such that the angle between its direction at $p$ and the direction of $px_n$ is at most a small $\omega$ to be chosen later. Let $z_n\in \gamma$ be such that $|pz_n|=r_n$.

We have \begin{eqnarray}\label{1} |x_nz_n|=\sqrt{2r_n^2(1-\cos\tilde\measuredangle x_npz_n)}=2r_n \sin{(\frac{\tilde\measuredangle x_npz_n}{2})}\leq r_n\cdot \omega. \end{eqnarray} Let us show that the angles $\tilde \measuredangle z_npy_n$ and $\tilde \measuredangle x_npy_n$ are very close to each other. We have \begin{eqnarray*} |x_ny_n|^2=r_n^2+R_n^2-2r_nR_n\cos\tilde\measuredangle x_npy_n,\\ |z_ny_n|^2=r_n^2+R_n^2-2r_nR_n\cos\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n. \end{eqnarray*} Subtracting the two equalities we get \begin{eqnarray*} 2r_nR_n(\cos\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n-\cos\tilde\measuredangle x_npy_n)=(|z_ny_n|-|x_ny_n|)(|z_ny_n|+|x_ny_n|). \end{eqnarray*}

This and (\ref{1}) imply \begin{eqnarray*} |\cos\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n-\cos\tilde\measuredangle x_npy_n|\leq \omega \frac{|z_ny_n|+|x_ny_n|}{2R_n}\leq \omega \frac{r_n+R_n}{R_n}\leq 2\omega. \end{eqnarray*} Since $|\arccos a-\arccos b|\leq C|a-b|^{1/2}$ for some fixed $C\geq 1$ and any $a,b\in [0,\pi]$, we obtain \begin{eqnarray}\label{2} |\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n-\tilde\alpha_n|\leq C\sqrt{2\omega}. \end{eqnarray} On the other hand \begin{eqnarray*} \measuredangle z_npy_n-\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n\geq (\measuredangle x_npy_n-\measuredangle z_npx_n)-(\tilde\alpha_n+C\sqrt{2\omega})\geq\\ \measuredangle x_npy_n-\tilde\alpha_n-(\omega+C\sqrt{2\omega})\geq \delta -(\omega+C\sqrt{2\omega}). \end{eqnarray*} Now let us choose $\omega$ so that $\omega+C\sqrt{2\omega}<\delta/2$. Then we get \begin{eqnarray}\label{3} \measuredangle z_npy_n-\tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n> \delta/2. \end{eqnarray}

Thus we reduced the problem to the case when the points $z_n$ lie on the same geodesic $\gamma$ and $|pz_n\leq |py_n|$. Now choose point $w_n\in \gamma$ such that $|pw_n|=|py_n|$. We have $\tilde\measuredangle w_npy_n\leq \tilde\measuredangle z_npy_n$. Hence by (\ref{3}) we have \begin{eqnarray}\label{4} \measuredangle w_npy_n-\tilde\measuredangle w_npy_n> \delta/2. \end{eqnarray} Thus now $|pw_n|=|py_n|$. Like in the previous step we can find another geodesic $\hat\gamma$ such that its direction at $p$ is very close to the directions at $p$ of the geodesics $py_n$. We choose points $t_n\in \hat \gamma$ such that $|pt_n|=|py_n|$. Repeating the argument as above we get for $n\gg 1$ $$\measuredangle w_npt_n-\tilde\measuredangle w_npt_n> \delta/4.$$ But $\measuredangle w_npt_n$ equals the angle between $\gamma$ and $\hat\gamma$, and $\tilde\measuredangle w_npt_n$ converges to this angle by definition. This is a contradiction. QED


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.