A compact topological group $G$ is called Van der Waerden if each homomorphism $h:G\to K$ to a compact topological group is continuous. By a classical result of Van der Waerden (1933) the groups $SO(2n+1,\mathbb R)$ are Van der Waerden, i.e., admit no discontinuous homomorphisms to compact topological groups.

On the other hand, Kallman proved that for every $n\in\mathbb N$ the Lie group $GL(n,\mathbb R)$ admits an injective homomorphism to the symmetric group $Sym(\mathbb N)$.

Problem. Does each infinite compact topological group $K$ admit a discontinuous homomorphism $h:K\to P$ to a Polish group $P$?

The answer to this problem is affirmative in three cases:

1) $K$ is solvable. In this case $K$ admits a homomorphism into an infinite abelian-by-finite group in which it is easy to construct a normal subgroup of countable index and the quotient homomorphism by this subgroup will be a discontinuous homomorphism to a countable discrete (and hence Polish) group;

2) $K$ is non-metrizable. In this case $K$ is not Wan der Waerden (see page 412 in the paper of Comfort) and hence $K$ admits a discontinuous homomorphism to some compact Lie group;

3) $K$ is not zero-dimensional. In this case it is possible to construct a continuous homomorphism $h:K\to O(n)\subset SL(n,\mathbb R)$ for some $n$ whose image $h(K)$ is not finite and being a Lie group is not zero-dimensional. Then the Kallman injective homomorphism $\varphi:k(K)\to Sym(\mathbb N)$ is necessarily discontinuous and so is the homomorphism $\varphi\circ h:K\to Sym(\mathbb N)$.

Those partial answers reduce the problem to the following its partial case.

Problem 0. Let $K$ be an infinite compact metrizable zero-dimensional topological group. Does $K$ admit a dicontinuous homomorphism to a Polish group?

Remark. If a compact topological group $K$ has no discontinuous homomorphism to a finite group, then for every $n\in\mathbb N$ it has only finitely many subgroups of index $n$. This can be shown using the limits by ultrafilters (see p.9 of https://arxiv.org/pdf/1108.5130.pdf). An example of a compact group with finitely many subgroups of a given finite index is the product $\prod_{n\ge 5}A_n$.

Question. Let $(k_n)_{n=5}^\infty$ be a sequence of natural numbers. Does the compact group $\prod_{n\ge 5}A_n^{k_n}$ admit a discontinuous homomorphism to a Polish group?

As was pointed out by @YCor, the Question is a partial case of a more general Conjecture 6.4 of Thomas and Zapletal.

  • 1
    $\begingroup$ I added the tag profinite-groups, since it's the same as being compact zero-dimensional. $\endgroup$ – YCor May 6 '17 at 8:43
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Automatic continuity (of homomorphisms into Polish groups) for infinite products of finite simple groups is discussed in this paper by Thomas-Zapletal (math.univ-lyon1.fr/~confluentes/CM/04/0402/Thomas.pdf). They say that no such group is known to satisfy automatic continuity, but that indeed products of growing alternating groups are plausible examples. $\endgroup$ – YCor May 6 '17 at 8:51
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ For a compact group, an obvious obstruction to Automatic Continuity is the existence of a subgroup of infinite countable index. If $(S_n)$ is a sequence of non-abelian groups, it's a result of Simon Thomas (J. Group Theory 1999) that $\prod S_n$ has no non-closed subgroup of countable index iff the rank of $S_n$ tends to $\infty$ (rank tends to $\infty$ is in the classical sense, described for instance here: mathoverflow.net/a/163690/14094). $\endgroup$ – YCor May 6 '17 at 9:05

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.