The following is the result of some "idle musings". I feel like it should be classical, but I do not even know what to look for.

Recall that in spaces (say, pointed topological spaces) there is a notion of a fibration sequence

$ F_f \xrightarrow{e} X \xrightarrow{f} Y.$

I do not want to recall the definition, but let me recall the following facts:

  1. $F_f$ is determined in an appropriate sense by $f$ (i.e. given any map $f$ there is an essentially unique way of completing to a fibration sequence).
  2. There is a canonical equivalence $F_e \simeq \Omega Y$, where $F_e \to F_f \xrightarrow{e} X$ is another fibration sequence.
  3. The induced sequence $\pi_0(F_f) \to \pi_0(X) \to \pi_0(Y)$ is exact. (Of course, exactness of a sequence of sets does not make incredibly much sense, but take $X$ and $Y$ to be loop spaces and $f$ a loop map if you want.)

From this it follows in particular that we get a long exact sequence relating the homotopy groups of $X, Y$ and $F_f$.

Now recall that given a space $X$, we can define the fundamental groupoid $\pi_{0,1}(X)$. This is a category with objects the points and morphisms the homotopy classes of paths. If $X$ is a loop space this can be made into a monoidal category in which every object is invertible, and if $X$ is a double loop space even a symmetric monoidal category. Now there is a notion of exact sequence for symmetric monoidal groupoids in which every object is invertible (see e.g. [1]).

My idle question is now the following: Given a morphism of spaces $f: X \to Y$, can we "complete" this to a sequence $\tilde{F}_f \xrightarrow{e} X \to Y$ satisfying the following properties:

  1. $\tilde{F}_f$ is determined by $f$ in an appropriate sense
  2. $\tilde{F}_e \simeq \Omega^2 Y$
  3. If $X, Y$ are double loop spaces and $f$ is a double loop map, then $\tilde{F}_f$ is also a double loop space, $e$ is a double loop map, and the sequence of symmetric monoidal groupoids in which every object is invertible $\pi_{0,1}(\tilde{F}_f) \to \pi_{0,1} X \to \pi_{0,1} Y$ is exact.

In particular then, the sequence $\tilde{F}_f \to X \to Y$ would induce a long exact sequence of "homotopy groupoids"

$\dots \to \Pi_n(\tilde{F}_f) \to \Pi_n(X) \to \Pi_n(Y) \to \Pi_{n-1}(\tilde{F}_f) \to \dots $

Here I put $\Pi_n(X) := \pi_{0,1}(\Omega^{2n} X)$. At the risk of rambling a bit, recall that any symmetric monoidal groupoid $E$ has two associated abelian groups, $\pi_0(E) = Pic(E)$ and $\pi_1(E) = Aut(1)$. Now for a loop space $X$ we get $\pi_i(\pi_{0,1}(X)) = \pi_i(X)$ for $i \in \{0,1\}$, so $\pi_0(\Pi_n(X)) = \pi_{2n}(X)$ and $\pi_1(\Pi_n(X)) = \pi_{2n+1}(X)$. At least for the definition of "exact sequence of symmetric monoidal groupoids in which every object is invertible" of [1] it is the case that this induces exact sequences on both $\pi_0$ and $\pi_1$, so the above long exact sequence automatically yields

$\dots \to \pi_{2n+2}(X) \to \pi_{2n+2}(Y) \to \pi_{2n}(\tilde{F}_f) \to \pi_{2n}(X) \to \pi_{2n}(Y) \to \dots$

$\dots \to \pi_{2n+3}(X) \to \pi_{2n+3}(Y) \to \pi_{2n+1}(\tilde{F}_f) \to \pi_{2n+1}(X) \to \pi_{2n+1}(Y) \to \dots$

[1] Enrico M. Vitale: A Picard-Brauer exact sequence of categorical groups

  • 2
    $\begingroup$ The usual fiber satisfies your condition 3, and in fact the map $\pi_{0,1}F_f\to ker (\pi_{0,1}f)$ is an iso on $\pi_0$ and an epi on $\pi_1$. I think it follows from this that the canonical map $\tilde F_f \to F_f$ is an effective epimorphism, and it would follow from condition 2 that there is always an effective epimorphism $\Omega^2Y\to\Omega Y$, a contradiction... $\endgroup$ – Marc Hoyois May 5 '17 at 17:43

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.