The dual to the category of commutative unital C*-algebras is equivalent to the category of compact Hausdorff spaces, a concrete category. Can the dual to the category of unital C*-algebras also be concretized, yielding a concrete notion of noncommutative topological space? If so, is there a known description of this concrete category in terms of sets with some structure and maps that preserve that structure (like how a compact Hausdorff space is a set with a collection of its subsets satisfying certain properties)?


The opposite of any concretizable category is concretizable: if $U : C \to \text{Set}$ is a faithful functor, then so is the composite

$$C^{op} \xrightarrow{U^{op}} \text{Set}^{op} \xrightarrow{\text{Hom}(-, 2)} \text{Set}.$$

Really we can pick any concretization of $\text{Set}^{op}$ we want; the one above corresponds to thinking of $\text{Set}^{op}$ as a particular category of Boolean algebras (e.g. the profinite ones, but also referred to as the complete atomic Boolean algebras).

This isn't particularly satisfying. A natural strengthening of the notion of concretizability is to ask for $U$ to be representable; then a category is concretizable in this sense (the nLab calls it representably concrete) iff it has a generator. Unfortunately the opposite of the category of C*-algebras does not admit a generator; equivalently, C*-algebras do not admit a cogenerator. This is because there are simple C*-algebras of arbitrarily large cardinality. This same argument prevents e.g. $\text{Grp}^{op}$ and $\text{Ring}^{op}$ from being representably concrete.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.