Let $M$ be a von Neumann algebra with predual $M_*$, and let $T\colon M\to M$ be a bounded, linear map. Let us say that $T$ is (sequentially) weak*-norm continuous if for every net (sequence) $(a_j)_j$ in $M$ that weak* converges to $a$ in $M$ we have $\lim_j \| T(a_j) - T(a) \| = 0$.

In particular, given $h\in M$, we may ask when the multiplication operator $L_h\colon M\to M$, $a\mapsto ha$, is (sequentially) weak*-norm continuous.

I suppose such operators on $M$ and elements of $M$ have been considered before. Is there an established terminology or some papers where this has been used?

Is it known when $M$ has an approximate unit $(h_j)_j$ such that multiplication by each $h_j$ is weak*-norm continuous?


Since taking the adjoint is continuous in both topologies, the set of $h$ such that the multiplication map has the said continuity property is $\ast$-closed, so we may assume that $h$ is self-adjoint -- let's take a look at its spectral decomposition. Suppose that the spectrum has a continous bit, say that $b\neq 0$ is an element of the spectrum that is not an eigenvalue. Then the sequence of spectral projections $E_{\mathbb{R} \setminus (b-\frac{1}{n}, b + \frac{1}{n})}$ converges to identity in weak*-topology but the images do not converge in norm. Therefore any non-zero element of the spectrum has to be an eigenvalue. Let's take a look at eigenspaces. If the orthogonal projection $P$ onto the eigenspace can be approximated from below by a sequence of projections in our von Neumann algebra that are not equal to $P$ then we get a contradiction again; this means that $P$ has to be a finite sum of minimal projections. If any set of the form $\mathbb{R} \setminus (-\varepsilon, \varepsilon)$ contains infinitely many eigenvalues then we can also construct an appropriate sequence of projections showing that the multiplication map is not weak*-norm continuous. Therefore $h$ has to be "compact", where we think of minimal projections as being one-dimensional. It is now important to check whether multiplication by a minimal projection is weak*-norm continuous.

Since $h$ is built from minimal projections, if we consider the type decomposition of $M$, $h$ only lives in the type I part, we can therefore disregard type II and type III parts. The type I algebras are always direct sums of algebras of the form $B(\mathsf{H}) \otimes L^{\infty}(X,\mu)$, where in our case the measures that appear have to be discrete.

Let's consider the factor case for a while. If the factor is finite dimensional then of course it works, so consider $B(\ell_2)$. A minimal projection is just a rank one projection if we consider the natural representation, say $p= |e_1\rangle\langle e_1|$, where $(e_n)_{n \in \mathbb{N}}$ is the canonical orthonormal basis. The sequence of partial isometries $v_n := |e_1\rangle \langle e_n|$ converges in weak*-topology to $0$ but the sequence $pv_n=v_n$ does not converge to $0$ in norm, so only the finite dimensional factors remain.

The last important case to consider is an algebra of the form $M_k \otimes \ell_{\infty}$ (the measure has to be discrete and the finite case is trivial). A minimal projection in this case is of the form $p=|e_1\rangle\langle e_1| \otimes \delta_1$. Let $(A_n)$ be a sequence of matrices that converges in weak*-topology. Each $A_n$ is of the form $A_n= (f_{ij}^{n})$, where $f_{ij} \in \ell_{\infty}$. We have that $pA_n$ is only the first row of $A_n$ multiplied by $\delta_1$, so it is the following vector $(\delta_1 f_{11}^n,\dots, \delta_1 f_{1k}^n)$. Its norm is equal to $\| \sum_{i=1}^{k} |\delta_1 f_{1i}|^2\|_{\infty}$. Because of the $\delta_1$ factor this function is supported at just one point, so the norm is $\sum_{i=1}^{k} |f_{1i}^{n}(1)|^2$ -- this surely converges to $0$ if the sequence $A_n$ converged to $0$ in weak*-topology.

The conclusion is that in the type decompostion of $M$ one just needs to consider bits of the form $M_n \otimes \ell_{\infty}^{k}$, where $k$ may be infinite.

  • $\begingroup$ Dear Mateusz, thank you for the thorough answer. This satisfyingly settles the case of "internal" weak*-norm-continuous operators (i.e., thus given by mutliplication by an element of $M$.) The situation might be different if one considers maps $T\colon M\to M$. In particular, if $F\subseteq M$ is finite-dimensional, and if $T\colon M\to F$ is normal, then $T$ is also weak*-norm-continuous. Thus, there tend to be many such maps, and I guess that if $M$ is hyperfinite then there are enough to approximate the identity on $M$ in some sense. $\endgroup$ – Hannes Thiel Jan 31 '17 at 9:56
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Yes, that's correct. Such a map has to have finite rank because it is, in particular, weak-norm continuous, where I really mean the weak topology in the Banach space meaning; it is known that only finite rank maps have this continuity property. $\endgroup$ – Mateusz Wasilewski Jan 31 '17 at 13:02

Your example of a multiplication operator has the property of being weak$^*$-continuous, and in that setting, we can say quite a lot, with an elementary proof.

Claim: Let $E$ be a Banach space and $T:E^*\rightarrow E^*$ be a weak$^*$-continuous operator (that is, the adjoint of some $S:E\rightarrow E$). Then the following are equivalent:

  1. For any bounded net $(a_j)$ in $E^*$ which is weak$^*$-convergent to 0, we have that $\|T(a_j)\| \rightarrow 0$.
  2. $S$ is a compact operator.
  3. $T$ is a compact operator.

Proof: That $S$ is compact if and only if $T$ is compact is Schauder's theorem. Set $X:=\{S(\omega):\omega\in E, \|\omega\|\leq 1\}$ and notice that (1) is equivalent to:

  1. For any bounded net $(a_j)$ in $E^*$ which is weak$^*$-convergent to 0, we have that $\langle a_j,\omega\rangle\rightarrow 0$ uniformly on $X$.

Then $S$ is compact if and only if $X$ is compact. If $X$ is compact, then a simple $\epsilon$-net argument shows that (4) holds (using that the net $(a_j)$ is assumed bounded). Conversely, suppose that $X$ is not compact, so there is $\epsilon>0$ such that $X$ admits no $2\epsilon$-net. For any finite-dimensional subspace $N\subseteq E$, any closed and bounded subset of $N$ is compact, and so the distance from $N$ to $X$ must be at least $\epsilon$, say. By Hahn-Banach we can find $a_N\in E^*$ and $\omega_N\in X$ with $\langle a_N,\omega \rangle=0$ for all $\omega\in N$, with $|\langle a_N, \omega_N \rangle| \geq \epsilon$ and with $\|a_N\|\leq 1$. The (bounded) net $(a_N)$ hence shows that (4) does not hold.

If $E$ is separable then you can consider (bounded) sequences in place of nets.

Thus, I believe, your original question is equivalent to asking when the (left) multiplication operator given by $h\in M$ is compact.

[ I stressed the word "bounded". If you allow unbounded nets then the condition becomes that $X$ has finite-dimensional span, i.e. that $S$ (equivalently $T$) is a finite-rank operator. In the sequence case, the Principle of Uniform Boundedness says you have to be bounded anyway. ]


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.