Let $\mathcal E=\mathsf{Sh}(\mathsf C,J)$. Let $A\rightarrowtail \Omega$ be a fixed subobject. For each $X$ in $\mathcal E$, define $T_A(X)$ to be a set of subobjects of $X$ as follows. $U\rightarrowtail X$ is in $T_A(X)$ if its characteristic arrow factors through $A\rightarrowtail X$.

I'm trying to prove the following. Suppose $(U_i\to X)$ is a $J$-covering family. If the pullback of $U\rightarrowtail X$ along each of the $U_i\to X$ is in $T_A(U_i)$, then $U\rightarrowtail X$ is in $T_A(X)$.

However, I'm not really getting anywhere. Even if I assume the site is superextensive, I'm still stuck with rectangular diagrams whose exterior and left square are pullbacks, and for such diagrams, the right square is a pullback iff the bottom left arrow is a universal strong epimorphism.

How can I prove this claim?


Let $ \chi : X \rightarrow \Omega$ be the characteristic function of $U$.

By definition of a subobject classifier, the characteristic function of the pullback of $U$ by $U_i \rightarrow X$ is just the composite $U_i \rightarrow X \overset{\chi}{\rightarrow} \Omega$.

Hence the proposition you are trying to prove boils down to the following fact:

if for all $i$, the map $ U_i \rightarrow X \overset{\chi}{\rightarrow} \Omega$ factor into $A \subset \Omega$ then $\chi$ factor into $A$, and this just the fact that $A$ is a sheaf.

  • $\begingroup$ Thanks! I'll try to work out the details later (I'm a novice at this). $\endgroup$ – Arrow Oct 18 '16 at 22:24

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.