Question: Should we post on arXiv only papers in publishable shape (or very close)?
This question should be distinguished from the following:
Should one post a paper on the arXiv if it is not intended to be published?
in the sense that a paper which has not a publishable "contents" can have a publishable "shape".
Moreover, a paper which is intended to be published can be not yet in a publishable shape.
Sometimes it happens that we start to write a paper, we develop some interesting new ideas, but then we do not continue the paper for several possible reasons:
- change of the research subject
- loss of motivation for this problem
- too difficult
Sometimes also we just want to share the current state of our work through a draft, even if all the proofs are not yet complete.
Whatever the reasons, the ideas contained in such drafts can be interesting and useful for the community, regardless of the state of advancement of the paper. So after this explanation:
Should we definitely not post such a paper on arXiv, even if its state is clearly specified at the beginning?