Is there a constant $K \in \mathbb{N}$ such that for every finite solvable group $G$, there exists a nilpotent subgroup $N \leq G$, and a subset $S \subseteq G$ with $|S| \leq K$, and $\langle N,S\rangle = G$ ?


No. Call the minimal cardinal of a subset $S$ such that $H\cup S$ generates $G$, the (generating) corank of $H$ in $G$. I claim that

There exists solvable (actually metabelian) finite groups for which the smallest corank of a nilpotent subgroup is arbitrary large.

Consider a nonempty finite index set $I$, of cardinal $n$. Consider for $i\in I$ copies $A_i$ of the group with 2 elements, $B_i$ copies of the group of 3 elements. Let $A_i$ act nontrivially on $B_i$ (but trivially on $B_j$ for $j\neq i$). Let $m$ be another integer and consider $$G=G_{m,n}=\left(\prod_i A_i\right)\ltimes \left(\prod_i B_i^m \right)=\prod_i (A_i\ltimes B_i^m)\simeq (C_2\ltimes_{\pm} C_3^m)^n.$$

Let $H$ be a subgroup of $G$.

First assume that $H$ is a 2-group. Then conjugating and enlarging $H$, we can assume that $H$ equals the 2-Sylow $\prod A_i$. Hence the corank of $H$ is equal to the minimal number of generators of $\prod B_i^m$ as a $(\prod A_i)$-module, which is bounded above (actually equal but we don't care) by the minimal number of generators of $C_3^m$ as a $C_2$-module, and this number is clearly $m$ (the $C_2$-action in this case being scalar, it is useless to reduce the generating rank).

Let now $H$ be arbitrary. Let $J\subset I$ be the set of $i$ such that the projection $H\to A_i$ is onto, and $K$ its complement. Then looking at the abelianization shows that the corank of $H$ is $\ge \#(K)$. Now assume that $H$ is nilpotent. Denote by $N$ the 3-torsion in $G$, which is a subgroup (the unique 3-Sylow). Then $N\cap H$ is the 3-Sylow in $H$; it is contained in $\prod_{i\in K}B_i^m$ (otherwise its projection on $B_j^m$ is nonzero for some $j\in J$ and having in mind that in $H$, elements of order 2 commute with elements of order 3 as in any nilpotent group, we contradict the fact that the projection of $H$ on $A_j$ is nontrivial since the action of the nontrivial element of $A_j$ on $B_j^m$ fixes only zero). Thus after killing $\prod_{i\in K}A_i\ltimes B_i^m$, we are in the case when $H$ is a 2-subgroup, and we see that the corank of $H$ is at least equal to $m$, provided that $J$ is not empty. If $J$ is empty, then $n=\#(K)$ and hence the corank of $H$ is at least $n$.

This proves that the corank of any nilpotent subgroup $H$ of $G_{m,n}$ is at least $\min(m,n)$.

  • $\begingroup$ PS: the 3-Sylow $\prod B_i^m$ has corank $n$; the 2-Sylow $\prod A_i$ has corank at most $m$ ($=m$ by the above), so it follows that the smallest corank of a nilpotent subgroup in $G_{m,n}$ is exactly $\min(n,m)$. $\endgroup$ – YCor May 6 '15 at 19:58
  • $\begingroup$ Do you think that it is possible to replace 'nilpotent' by some larger proper subclass of the finite solvable groups, so that the claim will become true? $\endgroup$ – Pablo May 7 '15 at 4:30
  • $\begingroup$ A candidate could be the class of finite supersolvable groups. $\endgroup$ – Pablo May 7 '15 at 7:04
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ It lacks of motivation... supersolvable would not work. Replace in the above construction $C_2$ with $C_3$ for $A_i$ and $C_3$ with $C_2^2$ for $B_i$ (with non-trivial $C_3$-action). $\endgroup$ – YCor May 7 '15 at 7:35
  • 2
    $\begingroup$ Then try to prove or disprove it... $\endgroup$ – YCor May 7 '15 at 12:38

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.