M.Newman raised several questions in his 1957 paper on modular forms.

Definition: $H_n$ is the subclass of all zero-free weakly modular forms of weight 0 on $\Gamma_0(n)$, where $n$ is a composite number. Additionally, any $h\in H_n$ is holomorphic at cusps other than $i\infty$ and meromorphic at $i\infty$.

One of the most interesting conjecture is:

Conjecture: Every weakly modular form of weight 0 on $\Gamma_0(n)$ holomorphic at cusps other than $i\infty$ and meromorphic at $i\infty$ is a linear combination of functions in $H_n$.

Question: Does this conjecture have a positive answer?

  • 3
    $\begingroup$ I believe Newman states his conjecture and defines the relevant notation in his 1957 PLMS paper (instead of the 1959 one). In particular, $H_{n}$ is defined on page 342 and the conjecture is stated on page 343. I've taken the liberty of editing the question and changing the link. $\endgroup$ Jan 11 '15 at 17:45

First, I think your definition of $H_{n}$ does not agree with Newman's definition. Newman says the following: "Let $H_{n} \subset G_{n}$ be the set of functions of $G_{n}$ with non-negative valence at all parabolic points of $Q_{n}$ other than $\tau = i\infty$." Here $G_{n}$ is the set of modular functions that are expressible in terms of the Dedekind eta-function (which I will refer to as eta-quotients). So Newman is asking if the set of level $n$ eta-quotients of weight $0$ span the space of modular functions holomorphic everywhere except at $i\infty$.

If $n$ is squarefree, any weight zero modular function that is non-vanishing on the upper half plane is a constant multiple of an eta quotient (see Winfried Kohnen's paper). However, this is not true when $n$ is not squarefree. The reason is that any weight zero eta-quotient has rational Fourier coefficients, and hence corresponds to an element of $\mathbb{Q}(X_{0}(n))$. However, when $n$ is not squarefree, the cusps of $X_{0}(n)$ need not be rational. Given any two cusps $p_{1}$ and $p_{2}$, the divisor class $p_{1} - p_{2}$ is torsion in $J_{0}(n)$ (by a Theorem of Drinfeld and Manin) and as a consequence, there is a modular function all of whose zeroes are at $p_{1}$ and all of whose poles are at $p_{2}$. In general, this modular function will not have rational Fourier coefficients, and this modular function would be included in $H_{n}$ (via your definition), but not via Newman's definition.

I've written a paper with John Webb (on arXiv here) where we study some related questions to Newman's conjecture and do some more computations. We show that if $n$ is composite, the span of $H_{n}$ has finite codimension in the space of all modular functions holomorphic everywhere except infinity. Also, Newman's conjecture is true for all composite $n \leq 300$ with the possible exceptions of $n = 121$ and $n = 209$.

However, it seems likely that $n = 121$ may be a genuine exception to his conjecture. The form $f(z) = \frac{\eta(121z)^{22}}{\eta(11z)^{2}}$ has weight $10$ and has a zero of order $110$ at $i \infty$ and is nonzero everywhere else. As a consequence, if $g(z)$ is a modular function holomorphic everywhere except at infinity, then $f(z)^{r} g(z)$ is a holomorphic modular form of weight $10r$ provided $110r$ is $\geq$ the order of pole of $g(z)$ at infinity. For $2 \leq r \leq 8$, the subspace of $M_{10r}(\Gamma_{0}(121))$ generated by eta quotients has codimension $90$ - this suggests that $H_{121}$ may have codimension $90$ in the space of all modular functions with poles only at $i\infty$.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.