It is well-known that in Sacks model there are P-points and even Ramsey ultrafilters, but what the usual (i.e. findable in the literature) proofs for these facts do is proving that ground model P-points (or Ramsey ultrafilters) are preserved by Sacks forcing (i.e. still generate an ultrafilter in the extension). Thus, the only examples of P-points or Ramsey ultrafilters that I know of in Sacks model are those that already existed in the ground model, hence they all have weight $\aleph_1$ (i.e. they are generated by $\aleph_1$ many elements, since the ground model satisfies CH). So my question is:

Is it known whether there are P-points and/or Ramsey ultrafilters of weight $\aleph_2$ in Sacks model? (actually my real question is: if yes, how are they constructed?, I guess)


I assume that by "the Sacks model" you mean the result of a countable-support iteration of Sacks forcing for $\omega_2$ steps over a ground model satisfying GCH. On that understanding, think the answer to your question is no. If $U$ is a P-point in the final model, then, by a reflection argument, there will be ordinals $\alpha<\omega_2$ such that $U\cap V[G_\alpha]$ is a P-point in $V[G_\alpha]$ (where $G_\alpha$ is the part of the generic ultrafilter that was produced by the first $\alpha$ stages of the iteration). Since $V[G_\alpha]$ satisfies CH, this P-point $U\cap V[G_\alpha]$ is generated by $\aleph_1$ sets. Furthermore, because it's a P-point, it will be preserved through the later stages (from $\alpha$ to $\omega_2$) of the iteration. That means that the $\aleph_1$ generators of $U\cap V[G_\alpha]$ actually generate all of $U$ in the final model.

  • $\begingroup$ Yes, that's exactly what I meant by "the Sacks model"... and thanks for your answer! Now I'm wondering, since your argument here uses that P-points are preserved, what happens to other kinds of ultrafilters (that are not preserved)? In other words, do you know if Sacks model has any ultrafilters of weight $\aleph_2$ at all? $\endgroup$ – David Fernandez-Breton Jun 3 '14 at 17:58
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @DavidFernandezBreton Yes, it's a theorem of ZFC that there are always ultrafilters on $\omega$ that can't be generated by fewer than $2^{\aleph_0}$ sets. The proof uses an independent family $F$ of $2^{\aleph_0}$ sets and forms the ultrafilter generated by the sets in $F$ and the complements of all intersections of infinitely many sets from $F$. $\endgroup$ – Andreas Blass Jun 3 '14 at 18:31

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.