2
$\begingroup$

The Hahn Embedding Theorem asserts that for any (linearly) ordered abelian group $\Lambda$, there exists a linearly ordered indexing set $\Omega$ such that $\Lambda$ admits an order-preserving group embedding in the subgroup $\Lambda_\Omega$ of $\mathbb{R}^\Omega$ consisting of those entries with well-ordered support. ($\Lambda_\Omega$ is itself an ordered abelian group.)

This result has been extended in various directions, for example to lattice-ordered groups, and to the case where the given group is not abelian.

What I would like to know is if there is an equivariant version of this result. Let $\mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda)$ denote the group of order-preserving group automorphisms ($o$-automorphisms) of the ordered abelian group $\Lambda$.

Does there exist a linearly ordered set $\Omega$, an $o$-embedding $h:\Lambda\to\Lambda_\Omega$ and an embedding $\eta:\mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda)\to \mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda_\Omega)$ ($\gamma\mapsto\eta_\gamma$) such that $$\eta_\gamma\cdot h=h\cdot \gamma?$$ In addition, can $\Omega$ be chosen so that $\mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda_\Omega)$ acts transitively on the positive elements of $\Lambda_\Omega$?

Looking at A. H. Clifford's proof (Proc. Amer. Math. Soc., 5 (1954) 860-863), it seems plausible that extending $o$-automorphisms of $\Lambda$ in the required way might be possible, but I may well be overlooking some additional hypothesis. There are some promising-sounding papers, such as M. Droste and R. Goebel "The Automorphism Groups of Hahn Groups", but unfortunately I don't have access to this. (It sounds from the review on mathscinet that it doesn't address the question above.)

In any case, I imagine that questions like this have been asked -- and answered -- before, hence the reference-request tag.

EDIT (9 July 2014): Here's an outline of how I think one could answer the main question above in the affirmative.

The Hahn Embedding Theorem already gives an embedding of an arbitrary $\Lambda$ in $\Lambda_{\Omega}$ where $\Omega$ is (isomorphic to) the linearly ordered set of principal convex subgroups of $\Lambda$, that is, those convex subgroups generated (as a convex subgroup) by a single element. Let's write $\alpha_g$ for a typical element of $\mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda)$. Each $\alpha_g\in\mathrm{Aut}^+(\Lambda)$ induces an order-preserving permutation $\rho_g$ of the set of principal convex subgroups, and thus of $\Omega$. This gives an $o$-automorphism $\sigma_g$ of $\Lambda_\Omega$ that has the "same" effect on the principal convex subgroups of $\Lambda_\Omega$ as $\alpha_g$ has on $\Lambda$: that is, $h\cdot\alpha_g(\Lambda_0)$ and $\sigma_g\cdot h(\Lambda_0)$ span the same convex subgroup of $\Lambda_\Omega$, for convex subgroups $\Lambda_0$ of $\Lambda$.

Next, we can rescale the $\omega$th entry of an element of $\Lambda_\Omega$ (by multiplying by a positive real number $\kappa_\omega$) for $\omega\in\Omega$, and add suitable multiples of the $\omega$th entry to subsequent entries in such a way that we obtain an $o$-automorphism $\bar{\alpha}_g=\tau_g\cdot\kappa_g\cdot\sigma_g$ of $\Lambda_\Omega$ such that $h\cdot\alpha_g=\bar{\alpha}_g\cdot h$. Here $\kappa_g=(\kappa_\omega)$ is the coordinatewise rescaling map, and $\tau_g$ is a `unitary' map, which can be thought of as an infinite-dimensional analogue of an upper triangular matrix with real entries and diagonal entries equal to one, which records the effect of adding multiples of the $\omega$th entry to the $\omega'$th entry ($\omega<\omega'$).

But my suspicion remains that this particular wheel was invented a long time ago.

$\endgroup$

Your Answer

By clicking "Post Your Answer", you acknowledge that you have read our updated terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy, and that your continued use of the website is subject to these policies.

Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.