We say that a complex surface $S$ is isogenous to an (unmixed) product if there exists a finite group $G$, acting faithfully on two smooth projective curves $C_1$ and $C_2$ and freely on their product (with the diagonal action), so that $S$ is isomorphic to $(C_1 \times C_2)/G$.

If $S =(C_1 \times C_2)/G$ is any surface isogenous to a product, the two natural projections of $C_1 \times C_2$ induces two fibrations $f_1 \colon S \to C_1/G$ and $f_2 \colon S \to C_2/G$, whose smooth fibres $F_1$ and $F_2$ are isomorphic to $C_2$ and $C_1$, respectively. Moreover, since the action of $G$ on the product is free, all the singular fibres of $f_1$ and $f_2$ are multiple of smooth curves.

Let us consider now the group $\textrm{Tors(Pic}^0 S)$. Inside this group naturally lives the subgroup $H$ generated by $f_1^* \textrm{Tors(Pic}^0 C_1/G)$ and $f_2^* \textrm{Tors(Pic}^0 C_2/G)$.

Question. Are there conditions on $C_1$, $C_2$, $G$ and the actions ensuring that $H=\textrm{Tors(Pic}^0 S)?$ In other words, when the torsion part of the Picard group of $S$ is determined by the torsion parts of the bases $C_1/G$ and $C_2/G$ of the two natural fibrations?


1 Answer 1


I think the answer to the question as it is stated is negative: if I do understand correctly the question I can prove that, if $G$ is abelian and both curves $C_i/G$ are rational, this is never true.

Indeed, since ${\mathbb P}^1$ has no torsion, $H$ is trivial, so it is enough if I construct a non trivial torsion bundle on $S$.

Let $p_1,\ldots,p_r$ be the critical values of $f_1$. These are the points whose fibre are not reduced, say of multiplicity $m_i>1$; as you know very well, since $C_1/G$ is rational and $ G $ is abelian, $r\geq 2$ and each $m_i$ is a divisor of the l.c.m. of the other $m_j$. In particular, up to renumbering the points, I can suppose that $d:=\gcd(m_1,m_2)>1$.

Set $n_i:=\frac{m_i}{d}$, call respectively $F'$ and $F''$ the reduced fibres over $p_i$ and $p_2$, so that $m_1F'$ and $m_2F''$ are fibres of $f_1$. Then the divisor $D:=n_1F'-n_2F''$ is a nontrivial d-torsion divisor. Indeed $dD=m_1F'-m_2F''=f_1^*p_1-f_1^*p_2$ is principal, and by the standard results on the normal bundles of a multiple fibre taken with the reduced structure $$lD_{|F'}=l(n_1F'-n_2F'')_{|F'}=ln_1F'_{|F'}$$ is trivial iff $ln_1$ is a multiple of $m_1$, that is iff $d$ divides $l$.

Let me add some comments. Even if we remove my assumptions, my construction, for each pair of $m_i$ not relatively prime on the same side, produces a torsion bundle, and I do not see any reason for it to be in $H$ even when $H$ is very big. Still these torsion bundle are determined by the fibrations, so I would modify your question as follows

Question: Under which assumptions is the group generated by $H$ and the bundles constructed above the whole torsion group of $S$?

That could be true in a wider range of cases. One could try to prove it in the regular+abelian case by using a theorem of Armstrong as it was used here for computing some fundamental groups.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service and acknowledge you have read our privacy policy.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.