What is the finest free topological group $H$ with generators ${x_{1},x_{2},...}$ so that $x^{m_{n}}_n\rightarrow 1$ for all sequences $m_{1},m_{2},...$?

Is $H \simeq K$, with $K$ the natural subspace (of eventually constant sequences) of the inverse limit of finitely generated discrete free groups $F\{x_1,x_2,...x_n\}$}?

To make the question clear, let $G$ be the free group with generators ${x_{1},x_{2},...}$.

Let $L$ denote the partially ordered set of all topologies $\tau$ so that $(G,\tau)$ is a topological group and so that $\tau_1 \leq \tau_2 \iff \tau_1 \subset \tau_2$. Employing unions of topologies, it is straightforward to show $lub(A)$ exists for each $A \subset L$, and thus, (since $K$ satisfies all the conditions of the question except possibly being finest), $H$ exists.

The bonding maps $F\{x_1,x_2,...x_n\} \rightarrow F\{x_1,x_2,...x_{n-1}\}$ delete $x_n$ from each word, and note $K \leq H$.

To see why the question is nontrivial, $H \neq K$ in the related category SeqGrp (in which all spaces are sequential, and group multiplication is merely required to be jointly continuous over convergent sequences).

  • $\begingroup$ What is the proof of the statement in SeqGrp? It might help to provide some insight into the topological group case. $\endgroup$ – Will Sawin Dec 7 '13 at 22:31
  • $\begingroup$ I haven't yet understood Will's answer but maybe this follows from his answer: say that a net $(w_i)$ in the free group converges to 1 if there exists $k$ such that we can write $w_i=v_{i,1}\dots v_{i,k}$, with $v_{i,j}=c_{i,j}x_{m_{i,j}}^{n_{i,j}}c_{i,j}^{-1}$ and $\lim_im_{i,j}=\infty$ for all $j$; then I'd guess there exists a group topology for which these are precisely the nets tending to 1. Then for such a topology, the sequence $(w_n)$ defined by $w_n=x_nx_{n+1}\dots x_{2n}$ does not tend to 1, although it tends to 1 in the inverse limit topology. $\endgroup$ – YCor Dec 7 '13 at 23:25
  • $\begingroup$ (continued) the corresponding basis of neighborhoods of the identity would be $(V_f)$, where $f$ ranges over self-functions of the non-negative integers, where $V_f=\bigcup_{N}V_{f,N}$ and $V_{f,N}$ is the set of product of at most $f(N)$ conjugates of powers of the $x_n$ for $n\ge N$. $\endgroup$ – YCor Dec 7 '13 at 23:43
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Thanks for the thoughtful replies. To justify $H \neq K$ in SeqGrp: arxiv.org/abs/1105.6363 constructs When Q=1 a planar continuum X whose fundamental group pi1(X), (with quotient topology inherited from the space of based loops) is the free group on countably many generators, with such topology it is not in TopGrp, but is in SeqGrp. pi1(X) enjoys advertised properties and is finer than $K$. $\endgroup$ – Paul Fabel Dec 8 '13 at 3:03
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @YvesCornulier: I think you want your self-functions to be unbounded. Then your basis of neighborhoods defines a group topology - proof by checking all the conditions, essentially the same as in my answer. This gives a topology that is finer than $K$ but coarser than the topology in my answer. In your topology $x_1^n x_n x_1^{-n}$ converges to $1$ while in mine it does not. $\endgroup$ – Will Sawin Dec 8 '13 at 6:25

I think I can show that $H \neq K$.

We will think about functions that can be constructed using the group operations and constant elements of the group, like $f(y_1,y_2,y_3) = x_4^2 y_1 y_2 x_3^{-1} y_3$.

Consider the following topology: A set $U$ is open if, for each $k$-variable function $f$ such that $f(1,\dots, 1) \in U$, there is a constant $N$ such that for all $(n_1,\dots, n_k)$ a tuple of natural numbers $\geq N$ and $(m_1,\dots, m_k) \in \mathbb Z$, $f( x_{n_1}^{m_1},\dots, x_{n_k}^{m_k} )\in U$. It is easy to see that this is a topology and that inversion and translation are continuous.

Next we check that composition is continuous. Let $U$ be an open neighborhood of the identity. We need to check that the inverse image of $U$ under the composition map contains the product of two open neighborhods of the identity. Choose a countable enumeration of all functions, where say $f_i$ is the $i$th function. This gives a total ordering. For $U_1$ to each function $f_i$ such that $f_i(1,\dots, 1) =1$ we assign the constant $N$ which is the min over all $f_j$ such that $j\leq i$ and $f_i(1,\dots,1)f_j(1,\dots,1)=1$ of the constant assigned to $f_if_j$ by $U$. Then let $U_1$ be the union of the image of every function with $x_{n_i}^{m_i}$ plugged in for $n_i \geq N(f)$. Similarly, let $U_2$ be the same thing but with the composition in the opposite order. Then $U_1$ and $U_2$ are open, and $U_1U_2 \subset U$.

So this is a topological group. We can verify that $x_n^{m_n} \to 1$ using the definition of the open set $U$, and its topology is finer than $K$ - construct an open set where $N$ goes to $\infty$ very rapidly depending on the function.

Indeed, this is $H$:

Let $U$ be an open neighborhood of the identity of $H$. For each sequence $m_n$, there is an $N$ large enough such that $x_n^{m_n} \in U$ for $n \geq N$. So there exists a universal constant $N$ such that $x_n^{m} \in U$ for all $n \geq N$ and all $m$. (If not, then build a sequence $m_n$ from the counterexamples to the sequence of claims, for each $N$, that $N$ is a universal constant.)

Then for each open set and each function such that $f(1,\dots ,1 )$ is in the open set, choose a product of neighborhoods of the identity in the inverse image of the open set under the function, and take the max of the $N$ for each of them. So each open set of $H$ is open in our topology.

| cite | improve this answer | |
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ What do you mean by $(n_1,\dots,n_k)\ge N$? I can't guess what do $n_i,N$ denote (are $n_i$ integers? elements of the group? which ordering are you considering?) $\endgroup$ – YCor Dec 7 '13 at 23:14
  • $\begingroup$ Sorry that notation is wrong. I'll fix it. $\endgroup$ – Will Sawin Dec 7 '13 at 23:18

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.