Consider two positive integers $x \ne y$ and let $n = max\{\lfloor \log_2{x} \rfloor +1 ,\lfloor \log_2{y} \rfloor +1 \}$. Choose a prime $p$ randomly from the first $3n$ primes. What is the probability that $x \bmod p = y \bmod p$?
I believe it is at most $1/3$. My reasoning is that there are only $n$ primes at most for which $x \bmod p = y \bmod p$. Does this make sense and is there a self contained proof?
I am interested in upper and lower bounds for this probability, especially those that hold for large $n$.
The same question is also at https://math.stackexchange.com/questions/567230/probability-of-equality-mod-p where an upper bound of $2/9$ is now conjectured.