This might be ridiculously obvious, but...

For each $n \in \mathbb{N}$, let $M_n$ denote the manifold of $n \times n$ matrices with real entries. It is well known that the $n$-dimensional determinant function $d_n:M_n \to \mathbb{R}$ is a Morse function if and only if $n = 2$ since the zero matrix is a degenerate critical point of $d_n$ whenever $n > 2$. (See the simple homework exercise in this pdf for a proof).

My question is as follows:

For a given $n$, is there a characterization of the sub-manifolds of $M_n$ for which $d_n$ is a Morse function?

Just to be clear, by Morse function I mean that $d_n$ must have:

  1. Isolated critical points (not necessarily finitely many), and
  2. Non-degenerate Hessian at each critical point.

For general subspaces of $M_n$ it seems that the critical set of $d_n$ would not be isolated (one can easily construct examples of critical subspaces), so if there is a Morse-Bott theory for submanifolds of $M_n$ that would be good to know as well.


2 Answers 2


I'm not sure exactly what a characterization would be. Is there a characterization of the submanifolds of $\mathbb R^n$ for which $x_1$ is a Morse function?

Critical points of the submanifold will come in two forms - critical points of $M_n$ that lie on the submanifold, and noncritical points of $M_n$ that become critical in the submanifold. I don't know how to handle the second type but there is a very nice characterization of the critical points of $M_n$ - they are the matrices of rank at most $n-2$.

The matrices of rank $n-2$ have a Hessian of rank $4$, so any submanifold that includes those points must be no more than $4$-dimensional. In addition, the submanifold must also intersect transversely the submanifold of matrices of rank exactly $n-2$ (and there is another condition to ensure the Hessian is degenerate if the dimension is less than $4$)

The matrices of rank $n-3$ and lower have a Hessian that is entirely zero, so any positive-dimensional submanifold on which the function is Morse must avoid those matrices entirely.

The easiest way to see that these facts are true is to apply a linear transformation to put the matrix into Smith normal form, so that you only have to consider one matrix of each rank - the one that is zero outside the diagonal and has ones, then zeroes, on the diagonal.

  • $\begingroup$ Will, thanks for the partial answer regarding critical points of $M_n$. Regarding the characterization of submanifolds of $\mathbb{R}^n$ for which the first coordinate is a Morse function, see mathoverflow.net/questions/102956/… and set $M = \mathbb{R}^n$ and let $\mu$ be the function which extracts the first coordinate... $\endgroup$ Jan 13, 2013 at 20:54

Suppose that $M$ is a manifold, $S$ is a submanifold and $\newcommand{\bR}{\mathbb{R}}$ $f: M\to\bR$ is a smooth function. Let $T_S^*M\subset T^*M$ be the conormal bundle of $S$. Let $\Gamma_{df}\subset T^*M$ denote the graph of the differential of $f$, $df: M\to T^*M$, $\Gamma_{df}=df(M)$.

Then both $T^*_SM$ and $\Gamma_{df}$ are lagrangian submanifolds of $T^*M$. The function $f|_S$ is Morse iff the above two Lagrangian submanifolds intersect transversally. For a proof, see page 3 of these notes.


Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.