You are given a complex Hilbert space $H$ with two equivalent Hilbert space structures $<,>$ and $<,>'$. Define $<,>''=<,> + <,>'$ to be the sum of our two scalar products. Suppose you are given a complex symmetric bilinear form $B: H\times H \to \Bbb C$, with norm $c$ over $<,>''$ i.e. $$B(x,x) \leq c(|x|^2 + |x|'^2) , \ x \in H. $$ Does there exist complex symmetric bilinear forms $A$ and $C$, such that $B=A+C$ and $$A(x,x) \leq c|x|^2 , \ x \in H, $$ $$C(x,x) \leq c|x|'^2 , \ x \in H. $$ It is clear that if $A$ and $C$ have norm less then $c$ with respect to the respective norms, then $B$ has norm less then $c$ with respect to the "sum" norm. My questions is, do all operatods $B$ arise this way?

Probably not. However I keep thinking about this on and off, and as embarassing as it is, I can't come up with a counterexample even in the $\Bbb C^n$ case.


I think you mean $|B(x,x)| \leq c(|x|^2 + |x|'^2)$, etc. As the problem is stated, you can take $A(x,y) = \langle x,y\rangle$ and $C(x,y) = B(x,y) - \langle x,y\rangle$.

Then the answer is no, there's a counterexample where $H$ is two-dimensional. First, let us not demand that $\langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle$ and $\langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle'$ be equivalent. Set $\langle \vec{x},\vec{y}\rangle = x_1\bar{y}_1$ and $\langle \vec{x},\vec{y}\rangle' = x_2\bar{y}_2$. Then $\langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle''$ is the standard inner product on ${\bf C}^2$ and the form $B(\vec{x},\vec{y}) = \frac{1}{2}(x_1 + x_2)(y_1 + y_2)$ has norm 1. But $|A(\vec{x},\vec{x})| \leq |\vec{x}|^2 = |x_1|^2$ for all $\vec{x}$ implies that $A(e_1,e_2) = A(e_2,e_1) = 0$, and similarly for $C$, so their sum cannot have nonzero off-diagonal terms. Thus, we cannot write $B = A + C$ for such $A$ and $C$.

Now modify that example by letting $\langle \vec{x},\vec{y}\rangle = (1-\epsilon)x_1\bar{y}_1 + \epsilon x_2 \bar{y}_2$ and $\langle \vec{x},\vec{y}\rangle' = \epsilon x_1\bar{y}_1 + (1 - \epsilon)x_2 \bar{y}_2$. For any $\epsilon > 0$, these are equivalent inner products. Let $B$ be as above; since $\langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle + \langle\cdot,\cdot\rangle'$ is the standard inner product for any $\epsilon$, $B$ has norm 1 independent of $\epsilon$. If you could find $A$ and $C$ as desired for any $\epsilon > 0$, then by compactness (take a cluster point) you could find $A$ and $C$ as desired for $\epsilon = 0$, which we just saw is impossible. So for some $\epsilon > 0$ the given $B$ cannot be decomposed in the desired way.

It's not hard to give explicit estimates on the off-diagonal entries of $A$ and $C$ in terms of $\epsilon$ (I guess $\sqrt{2\epsilon}$ is a bound), and this would allow you to give an explicit counterexample. But I prefer the preceding proof.

| cite | improve this answer | |

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.