Skip to main content
Texified, since problem was on front-page anyway
Source Link
David White
  • 30.3k
  • 9
  • 154
  • 250

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X$X$.

  1. X$X$ is compact.

  2. Xκ$X^\kappa$ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ$\kappa$.

  3. Xω1$X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X$X$ is compact, then Xκ$X^\kappa$ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X$X$ that is not compact, but Xω1$X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf. It follows that X$X$ is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un$U_0 \subset U_1 \subset \dots U_n \dots$ ... withwith the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X$\bigcup\lbrace U_n \; | \; n \in \omega \rbrace = X$.

For each J subset ω1$J \subset \omega_1$ of size n$n$, let UJ$U_J$ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un$\lbrace s \in X^{\omega_1} \; | \; s(\alpha) \in U_n$ for each α in J}$\alpha \in J \rbrace$. As the size of J increases$J$ increases, the set UJ$U_J$ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J$J$, but restricts more coordinates. If J$J$ has size n$n$, let us call UJ$U_J$ an open n$n$-box, since it restricts the sequences on n$n$ coordinates. Let F$F$ be the family of all such UJ$U_J$ for all finite J subset ω1.$J \subset \omega_1$

This F$F$ is a cover of Xω1$X^{\omega_1}$. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1$s \in X^{\omega_1}$. For each α in ω1$\alpha \in \omega_1$, there is some n$n$ with s(α) in Un$s(\alpha) \in U_n$. Since ω1$\omega_1$ is uncountable, there must be some value of n$n$ that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n$n$ occurs at least n$n$ times. Let J$J$ be the coordinates where this n$n$ appears. Thus, s$s$ is in UJ$U_J$. So F$F$ is a cover.

Since Xω1$X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0$F_0$. Let J*$J^*$ be the union of all the finite J$J$ that appear in the UJ$U_J$ in this subcover. So J*$J^*$ is a countable subset of ω1$\omega_1$. Note that J*$J^*$ cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J$J$ appearing in F0$F_0$ would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1$X^{\omega_1}$. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω$J^*=\omega$ is the first ω$\omega$ many coordinates. So F0$F_0$ is really a cover of Xω$X^\omega$, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1$s \in X^{\omega_1}$ by choosing s(n)$s(n)$ to be outside Un+1$U_{n+1}$, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s$s$ is in Un$U_n$ in fewer than n$n$ coordinates below ω$\omega$, and so s$s$ is not in any n$n$-box with J subset ω$J \subset \omega$, since any such box has n$n$ values in Un$U_n$. Thus, s$s$ is not in any set in F0$F_0$, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa$\kappa$.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X.

  1. X is compact.

  2. Xκ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ.

  3. Xω1 is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X is compact, then Xκ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X that is not compact, but Xω1 is Lindelöf. It follows that X is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un ... with the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X.

For each J subset ω1 of size n, let UJ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un for each α in J}. As the size of J increases, the set UJ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J, but restricts more coordinates. If J has size n, let us call UJ an open n-box, since it restricts the sequences on n coordinates. Let F be the family of all such UJ for all finite J subset ω1.

This F is a cover of Xω1. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1. For each α in ω1, there is some n with s(α) in Un. Since ω1 is uncountable, there must be some value of n that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n occurs at least n times. Let J be the coordinates where this n appears. Thus, s is in UJ. So F is a cover.

Since Xω1 is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0. Let J* be the union of all the finite J that appear in the UJ in this subcover. So J* is a countable subset of ω1. Note that J* cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J appearing in F0 would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω is the first ω many coordinates. So F0 is really a cover of Xω, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1 by choosing s(n) to be outside Un+1, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s is in Un in fewer than n coordinates below ω, and so s is not in any n-box with J subset ω, since any such box has n values in Un. Thus, s is not in any set in F0, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space $X$.

  1. $X$ is compact.

  2. $X^\kappa$ is Lindelöf for any cardinal $\kappa$.

  3. $X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if $X$ is compact, then $X^\kappa$ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space $X$ that is not compact, but $X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf. It follows that $X$ is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets $U_0 \subset U_1 \subset \dots U_n \dots$ with the union $\bigcup\lbrace U_n \; | \; n \in \omega \rbrace = X$.

For each $J \subset \omega_1$ of size $n$, let $U_J$ be the set $\lbrace s \in X^{\omega_1} \; | \; s(\alpha) \in U_n$ for each $\alpha \in J \rbrace$. As the size of $J$ increases, the set $U_J$ allows more freedom on the coordinates in $J$, but restricts more coordinates. If $J$ has size $n$, let us call $U_J$ an open $n$-box, since it restricts the sequences on $n$ coordinates. Let $F$ be the family of all such $U_J$ for all finite $J \subset \omega_1$

This $F$ is a cover of $X^{\omega_1}$. To see this, consider any point $s \in X^{\omega_1}$. For each $\alpha \in \omega_1$, there is some $n$ with $s(\alpha) \in U_n$. Since $\omega_1$ is uncountable, there must be some value of $n$ that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some $n$ occurs at least $n$ times. Let $J$ be the coordinates where this $n$ appears. Thus, $s$ is in $U_J$. So $F$ is a cover.

Since $X^{\omega_1}$ is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover $F_0$. Let $J^*$ be the union of all the finite $J$ that appear in the $U_J$ in this subcover. So $J^*$ is a countable subset of $\omega_1$. Note that $J^*$ cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the $J$ appearing in $F_0$ would be bounded and it could not cover $X^{\omega_1}$. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that $J^*=\omega$ is the first $\omega$ many coordinates. So $F_0$ is really a cover of $X^\omega$, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence $s \in X^{\omega_1}$ by choosing $s(n)$ to be outside $U_{n+1}$, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that $s$ is in $U_n$ in fewer than $n$ coordinates below $\omega$, and so $s$ is not in any $n$-box with $J \subset \omega$, since any such box has $n$ values in $U_n$. Thus, $s$ is not in any set in $F_0$, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable $\kappa$.

fixed typo.
Source Link
Joel David Hamkins
  • 236.4k
  • 44
  • 777
  • 1.4k

The answer is Yes.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X.

  1. X is compact.

  2. Xκ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ.

  3. Xω1 is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X is compact, then Xκ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X that is not compact, but Xω1 is Lindelöf. It follows that X is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un ... with the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X.

For each J subset ω1 of size n, let UJ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un for each α in J}. As the size of J increases, the set UJ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J, but restricts more coordinates. If J has size n, let us call UJ an open n-box, since it restricts the sequences on n coordinates. Let F be the family of all such UJ for all finite J subset ω1.

This F is a cover of Xω1. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1. For each α in ω1, there is some n with s(α) in Un. Since ω1 is uncountable, there must be some value of n that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n occurs at least n times. Let J be the coordinates where this n appears. Thus, s is in UJ. So F is a cover.

Since Xω1 is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0. Let J* be the union of all the finite J that appear in the UJ in this subcover. So J* is a countable subset of ω1. Note that J* cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J appearing in F0 would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω is the first ω many coordinates. So F0 is really a cover of Xω, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1 by choosing s(n) to be outside Un+1, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s is in Un in fewer than n coordinates below ω, and so s is not in any n-box with J subset ω, since any such box has n values in Un. Thus, s is not in any set in F0, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa.

The answer is Yes.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X.

  1. X is compact.

  2. Xκ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ.

  3. Xω1 is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X is compact, then Xκ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X that is not compact, but Xω1 is Lindelöf. It follows that X is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un ... with the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X.

For each J subset ω of size n, let UJ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un for each α in J}. As the size of J increases, the set UJ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J, but restricts more coordinates. If J has size n, let us call UJ an open n-box, since it restricts the sequences on n coordinates. Let F be the family of all such UJ for all finite J subset ω1.

This F is a cover of Xω1. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1. For each α in ω1, there is some n with s(α) in Un. Since ω1 is uncountable, there must be some value of n that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n occurs at least n times. Let J be the coordinates where this n appears. Thus, s is in UJ. So F is a cover.

Since Xω1 is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0. Let J* be the union of all the finite J that appear in the UJ in this subcover. So J* is a countable subset of ω1. Note that J* cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J appearing in F0 would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω is the first ω many coordinates. So F0 is really a cover of Xω, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1 by choosing s(n) to be outside Un+1, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s is in Un in fewer than n coordinates below ω, and so s is not in any n-box with J subset ω, since any such box has n values in Un. Thus, s is not in any set in F0, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa.

The answer is Yes.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X.

  1. X is compact.

  2. Xκ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ.

  3. Xω1 is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X is compact, then Xκ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X that is not compact, but Xω1 is Lindelöf. It follows that X is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un ... with the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X.

For each J subset ω1 of size n, let UJ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un for each α in J}. As the size of J increases, the set UJ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J, but restricts more coordinates. If J has size n, let us call UJ an open n-box, since it restricts the sequences on n coordinates. Let F be the family of all such UJ for all finite J subset ω1.

This F is a cover of Xω1. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1. For each α in ω1, there is some n with s(α) in Un. Since ω1 is uncountable, there must be some value of n that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n occurs at least n times. Let J be the coordinates where this n appears. Thus, s is in UJ. So F is a cover.

Since Xω1 is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0. Let J* be the union of all the finite J that appear in the UJ in this subcover. So J* is a countable subset of ω1. Note that J* cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J appearing in F0 would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω is the first ω many coordinates. So F0 is really a cover of Xω, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1 by choosing s(n) to be outside Un+1, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s is in Un in fewer than n coordinates below ω, and so s is not in any n-box with J subset ω, since any such box has n values in Un. Thus, s is not in any set in F0, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa.

Source Link
Joel David Hamkins
  • 236.4k
  • 44
  • 777
  • 1.4k

The answer is Yes.

Theorem. The following are equivalent for any Hausdorff space X.

  1. X is compact.

  2. Xκ is Lindelöf for any cardinal κ.

  3. Xω1 is Lindelöf.

Proof. The forward implications are easy, using Tychonoff for 1 implies 2, since if X is compact, then Xκ is compact and hence Lindelöf.

So suppose that we have a space X that is not compact, but Xω1 is Lindelöf. It follows that X is Lindelöf. Thus, there is a countable cover having no finite subcover. From this, we may construct a strictly increasing sequence of open sets U0 subset U1 subset ... Un ... with the union U{ Un | n in ω} = X.

For each J subset ω of size n, let UJ be the set {s in Xω1 | s(α) in Un for each α in J}. As the size of J increases, the set UJ allows more freedom on the coordinates in J, but restricts more coordinates. If J has size n, let us call UJ an open n-box, since it restricts the sequences on n coordinates. Let F be the family of all such UJ for all finite J subset ω1.

This F is a cover of Xω1. To see this, consider any point s in Xω1. For each α in ω1, there is some n with s(α) in Un. Since ω1 is uncountable, there must be some value of n that is repeated unboundedly often, in particular, some n occurs at least n times. Let J be the coordinates where this n appears. Thus, s is in UJ. So F is a cover.

Since Xω1 is Lindelöf, there must be a countable subcover F0. Let J* be the union of all the finite J that appear in the UJ in this subcover. So J* is a countable subset of ω1. Note that J* cannot be finite, since then the sizes of the J appearing in F0 would be bounded and it could not cover Xω1. We may rearrange indices and assume without loss of generality that J*=ω is the first ω many coordinates. So F0 is really a cover of Xω, by ignoring the other coordinates.

But this is impossible. Define a sequence s in Xω1 by choosing s(n) to be outside Un+1, and otherwise arbitrary. Note that s is in Un in fewer than n coordinates below ω, and so s is not in any n-box with J subset ω, since any such box has n values in Un. Thus, s is not in any set in F0, so it is not a cover. QED

In particular, to answer the question at the end, it suffices to take any uncountable kappa.