Skip to main content
replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this questionthis question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, is it true that every closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature is an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

[EDIT] Another possible definition of centro-affine curvature is what the Legendre transform (the natural bijection between a convex body and its polar) does to the volume locally. I'm adding 'convexity' tag because some extremal properties of ellipsoids might be relevant here.

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, is it true that every closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature is an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

[EDIT] Another possible definition of centro-affine curvature is what the Legendre transform (the natural bijection between a convex body and its polar) does to the volume locally. I'm adding 'convexity' tag because some extremal properties of ellipsoids might be relevant here.

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, is it true that every closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature is an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

[EDIT] Another possible definition of centro-affine curvature is what the Legendre transform (the natural bijection between a convex body and its polar) does to the volume locally. I'm adding 'convexity' tag because some extremal properties of ellipsoids might be relevant here.

added convexity tag and a remark explaining its relevance
Source Link
Sergei Ivanov
  • 32.4k
  • 2
  • 99
  • 154

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, if $M$ is ait true that every closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature, does it have to be is an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

[EDIT] Another possible definition of centro-affine curvature is what the Legendre transform (the natural bijection between a convex body and its polar) does to the volume locally. I'm adding 'convexity' tag because some extremal properties of ellipsoids might be relevant here.

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, if $M$ is a closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature, does it have to be an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, is it true that every closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature is an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.

[EDIT] Another possible definition of centro-affine curvature is what the Legendre transform (the natural bijection between a convex body and its polar) does to the volume locally. I'm adding 'convexity' tag because some extremal properties of ellipsoids might be relevant here.

Source Link
Sergei Ivanov
  • 32.4k
  • 2
  • 99
  • 154

surfaces of constant centro-affine curvature

It is well-known that every closed surface in $\mathbb R^3$ having constant Gauss curvature is a round sphere. Inspired by this question, I'd like to ask whether a similar rigidity holds for centro-affine curvature.

More precisely, let $M\subset\mathbb R^3$ be a smooth closed convex surface (i.e., the boundary of a convex body) enclosing the origin. Its centro-affine curvature at a point $p\in M$ can be defined as $$ K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-4} $$ where $K(p)$ is the Gauss curvature and $\nu(p)$ is the outer normal vector at $p$. (More generally, for a hypersurface in $\mathbb R^n$ it is $K(p)\cdot\langle p,\nu(p)\rangle^{-(n+1)}$.)

The nice thing about centro-affine curvature is that it is invariant under volume-preserving linear transformations. In particular, it is constant if $M$ is an ellipsoid centered at the origin (because such ellipsoids are equivalent to spheres). Is the converse true? In other words, if $M$ is a closed convex surface with constant centro-affine curvature, does it have to be an ellipsoid?

Remark. For curves in $\mathbb R^2$, the condition that the centro-affine curvature is constant boils down to a second-order ODE whose solutions are ellipses and only ellipses. In $\mathbb R^3$, it is a PDE that seems to have many more solutions locally (just like in the case of constant Gauss curvature). So, if there is rigidity, it should be global only.