Skip to main content
added 179 characters in body; added 4 characters in body; added 92 characters in body
Source Link

Edited to fix the example, as per Zack's suggestion.

Edit 2: So it turns out that when I think 'manifold' I tend to assume the nicest possible object. As I believe is standard, I would like to assume that all manifolds are 2nd countable and Hausdorff. Furthermore, let's say that our manifolds are connected and closed.

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal''$n$-universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $M = \mathbb{RP}^3 \sharp \mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $M$ and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $M$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

Edited to fix the example, as per Zack's suggestion.

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $M = \mathbb{RP}^3 \sharp \mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $M$ and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $M$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

Edited to fix the example, as per Zack's suggestion.

Edit 2: So it turns out that when I think 'manifold' I tend to assume the nicest possible object. As I believe is standard, I would like to assume that all manifolds are 2nd countable and Hausdorff. Furthermore, let's say that our manifolds are connected and closed.

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a '$n$-universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $M = \mathbb{RP}^3 \sharp \mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $M$ and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $M$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

deleted 31 characters in body
Source Link

Edited to fix the example, as per Zack's suggestion.

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $\mathbb{RP}^3$$M = \mathbb{RP}^3 \sharp \mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $\mathbb{RP}^3$ (say $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:0]$ and $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:1]$ in homogenous coordinates.)$M$ and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $\mathbb{RP}^3$$M$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $\mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $\mathbb{RP}^3$ (say $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:0]$ and $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:1]$ in homogenous coordinates.) and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $\mathbb{RP}^3$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

Edited to fix the example, as per Zack's suggestion.

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $M = \mathbb{RP}^3 \sharp \mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $M$ and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $M$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?

Source Link

Is it possible to improve the Whitney embedding theorem?

The Whitney embedding theorem states that any smooth $n$-manifold may be smoothly embedded into $\mathbb{R}^{2n}$. If we consider embeddings into more general $k$-dimensional manifolds, is it possible find a 'universal' manifold of dimension less than $2n$?

For example, a non-orientable 2-manifold cannot be embedded into $\mathbb{R}^3$, demonstrating the sharpness of the Whitney embedding theorem.

However, there are 3-manifolds into which we can embed any surface, such as $\mathbb{RP}^3$. Indeed, by the classification of surfaces we know that any surface may be decomposed as a connected sum of copies of $\mathbb{RP}^2$ and tori. In fact, by the monoid structure of closed surfaces under connected sums we may take this sum to have at most 2 copies of the projective plane. Now, embed 2 disjoint copies of the projective plane into $\mathbb{RP}^3$ (say $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:0]$ and $[x:y:z] \mapsto [x:y:z:1]$ in homogenous coordinates.) and arbitrarily many copies of the torus. Taking the connected sum of these we see that any closed surface is embeddable into $\mathbb{RP}^3$.

Can we do something similar in higher dimensions?