Skip to main content

Poincare Poincaré duality with boundary conditions

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by PoincarePoincaré duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks:

  • The "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$

  • If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard PoincarePoincaré duality for manifolds with boundary.

  • It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

Poincare duality with boundary conditions

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks:

  • The "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$

  • If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

  • It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

Poincaré duality with boundary conditions

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincaré duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks:

  • The "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$

  • If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincaré duality for manifolds with boundary.

  • It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

added 12 characters in body
Source Link
Pavol S.
  • 407
  • 3
  • 9

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks: the "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$ If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

  • The "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$

  • If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

  • It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks: the "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$ If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks:

  • The "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$

  • If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

  • It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

added 6 characters in body; edited tags
Source Link
Pavol S.
  • 407
  • 3
  • 9

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies ofIs there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and ofand of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks: the "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$ If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks: the "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$ If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

If $M$ is a compact oriented manifold with boundary then by Poincare duality the cohomology of $\Omega(M)$ (de Rham cohomology of $M$) is dual to the cohomology of $\Omega_0(M)$, where $\Omega_0(M)$ denotes differential forms vanishing on $\partial M$. This question is about a generalization of this fact to more complicated boundary conditions.

Suppose $M$ is a compact oriented $C^\infty$ manifold with corners. Its boundary is decomposed (by the corners) to faces (of dimension $\dim M -1$).

Let $V$ be a finite-dimensional vector space, and let us choose for every face $F\subset\partial M$ a subspace $V_F\subset V$. Let us consider the complex (of $V$-valued differential forms with boundary conditions given by $V_F$'s) $$\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}= \{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V;\quad \alpha|_F\in\Omega(F)\otimes V_F\text{ for all faces }F\}\subset\Omega(M)\otimes V.$$

The "naive dual" of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ is $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ with the pairing given by integration over $M$ ($\text{ann} V_F\subset V^*$ denotes the annihilator of $V_F$).

Is there a condition under which the pairing between the cohomologies of $\Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}}$ and of $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ is perfect? What is the reason for the fact that the pairing is not always perfect?

Some remarks: the "dual complex" $\Omega(M)_{V^*,\{\text{ann} V_F\}}$ can be described as $$\{\alpha\in\Omega(M)\otimes V^*;\quad \int_M\langle\alpha\wedge d\beta\rangle= (-1)^{\deg\alpha +1}\int_M\langle d\alpha\wedge \beta\rangle\quad \forall\beta\in \Omega(M)_{V,\{V_F\}} \}.$$ If $V_F=0$ for all $F$'s then we get the standard Poincare duality for manifolds with boundary.

It is possible that manifolds with corners is not the right picture; the question might be about any "reasonable" division of $\partial M$ into "faces" (of dimension $\dim\partial M$).

added 328 characters in body; added 28 characters in body
Source Link
Pavol S.
  • 407
  • 3
  • 9
Loading
edited tags
Link
John Klein
  • 18.8k
  • 53
  • 109
Loading
added 584 characters in body; deleted 4 characters in body
Source Link
Pavol S.
  • 407
  • 3
  • 9
Loading
Source Link
Pavol S.
  • 407
  • 3
  • 9
Loading