Skip to main content
Minor Math Jaxing
Source Link
Daniele Tampieri
  • 6.4k
  • 7
  • 30
  • 45

The$\DeclareMathOperator{\InjRad}{InjRad}$ The compactness is irrelevant, it is proved in 5.4 of "Riemannsche Geometrie im Grossen" by Detlef Gromoll, Wilhelm Klingenberg, and Wolfgang Meyer.

But let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds, then the same is true for complete ones.

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$$R<\InjRad_p$, then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$$$\lim \InjRad_{x_n}< \InjRad_x,$$ apply the above construction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$$\InjRad_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$$$\lim\ \InjRad_{x_n}> \InjRad_x$$ then apply the above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$$R>\InjRad_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

The compactness is irrelevant, it is proved in 5.4 of "Riemannsche Geometrie im Grossen" by Detlef Gromoll, Wilhelm Klingenberg, and Wolfgang Meyer.

But let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds, then the same is true for complete ones.

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$, then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply the above construction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply the above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

$\DeclareMathOperator{\InjRad}{InjRad}$ The compactness is irrelevant, it is proved in 5.4 of "Riemannsche Geometrie im Grossen" by Detlef Gromoll, Wilhelm Klingenberg, and Wolfgang Meyer.

But let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds, then the same is true for complete ones.

If $R<\InjRad_p$, then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim \InjRad_{x_n}< \InjRad_x,$$ apply the above construction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\InjRad_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \InjRad_{x_n}> \InjRad_x$$ then apply the above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\InjRad_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

+ref
Source Link
Anton Petrunin
  • 45k
  • 14
  • 135
  • 299

The compactness is irrelevant; iirrelevant, it is proved in 5.e4 of "Riemannsche Geometrie im Grossen" by Detlef Gromoll, Wilhelm Klingenberg, and Wolfgang Meyer.

But let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds, then the same is true for complete ones. (The same proof as in comact case works, but it is easier to do this way.)

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$, then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply the above consructionconstruction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then then apply the above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

The compactness is irrelevant; i.e if it is true for compact manifolds then the same is true for complete ones. (The same proof as in comact case works, but it is easier to do this way.)

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$ then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply above consruction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

The compactness is irrelevant, it is proved in 5.4 of "Riemannsche Geometrie im Grossen" by Detlef Gromoll, Wilhelm Klingenberg, and Wolfgang Meyer.

But let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds, then the same is true for complete ones.

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$, then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply the above construction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply the above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

added 3 characters in body
Source Link
Anton Petrunin
  • 45k
  • 14
  • 135
  • 299

The compactness is irrelevant; i.e if it is true for compact manifolds then the same is true for complete ones. (The same proof as in comact case works, but it is easier to do this way.)

The fact that InjRad is lower semicontinuous is obvious; i.e. if $x_n\to x$ then $$\liminf\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}\ge \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ Now let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds then the same true for complete ones.

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$ then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

Now ifIf there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply above consruction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction.. again.

The compactness is irrelevant; i.e if it is true for compact manifolds then the same is true for complete ones. (The same proof as in comact case works, but it is easier to do this way.)

The fact that InjRad is lower semicontinuous is obvious; i.e. if $x_n\to x$ then $$\liminf\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}\ge \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ Now let me show that if it is true for compact manifolds then the same true for complete ones.

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$ then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

Now if there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction...

The compactness is irrelevant; i.e if it is true for compact manifolds then the same is true for complete ones. (The same proof as in comact case works, but it is easier to do this way.)

If $R<\mathrm{InjRad}_p$ then one can construct a smooth metric on a sphere with an isometric copy of $B_R(p)$ inside.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}< \mathrm{InjRad}_x,$$ apply above consruction for $R$ slightly smaller than $\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. You get a compact manifold with non-continuous InjRad.

If there is a sequence of points $x_n\to x$ such that $$\lim\ \mathrm{InjRad}_{x_n}> \mathrm{InjRad}_x$$ then apply above construction for $p=x_n$ for large enough $n$ and $R>\mathrm{InjRad}_x$. That leads to a contradiction again.

deleted 62 characters in body
Source Link
Anton Petrunin
  • 45k
  • 14
  • 135
  • 299
Loading
Source Link
Anton Petrunin
  • 45k
  • 14
  • 135
  • 299
Loading