Skip to main content
broken link fixed, cf. https://math.meta.stackexchange.com/a/34713/228959
Source Link
Glorfindel
  • 2.8k
  • 6
  • 28
  • 38

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paperpaper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

replaced http://mathoverflow.net/ with https://mathoverflow.net/
Source Link

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this questionthis question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

added 746 characters in body
Source Link
Chris Wuthrich
  • 8.9k
  • 1
  • 36
  • 47

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ X = X^3.$$$$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ X = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help.

With the transformation $X = -n/x$ and $Y= ny/x$, the curve becomes isomorphic to the Weierstrass model $$ E_n\colon \ \ Y^2 - X\ Y - n\ Y = X^3.$$ The points in question are exactly the integral points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$ such that $X$ divides $n$. I do not see why the number of these points should be bounded independently of $n$; so my guess is that there is no bound and that it is going to be difficult to show this.

The curve $E_n$ has always two rational 3-torsion points $(0,0)$ and $(0,n)$. Unless $n$ is of the form $k\cdot (\tfrac{k-1}{2})^2$ for some integer $k\not\equiv 2\pmod{4}$, these are all the torsion points in $E_n(\mathbb{Q})$, otherwise there are 6 torsion points defined over $\mathbb{Q}$. Hence, if $n$ is not of the above form, then any integral point with $X$ dividing $n$ will be of infinite order and hence the rank will be at least $1$.

(Edit:) Now, I have a reason to believe that the number is bounded. As pointed out by Felipe Voloch in this question, the paper by Abramovich shows that:

if the conjecture by Lang and Vojta about rational poitns on varieties of general type holds, then the number of solutions is bounded as $n$ varies.

One has just to note that the equation $E_n$ is in fact minimal and that the curve $E_n$ is semistable for all $n$. For all primes $p$ dividing $n$, the curve has split multiplicative reduction with $3\cdot \text{ord}_p(n)$ components. For all primes $p$ dividing $27n+1$, the reduction can be shown to be multiplicative, as well.

Maybe a descent via three-isogeny could help to give an upper bound on the rank.

Source Link
Chris Wuthrich
  • 8.9k
  • 1
  • 36
  • 47
Loading