Skip to main content
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Sam Hopkins, YCor, abx, Andy Putman, Daniele Tampieri
Notice removed Improve details by Arnold
Bounty Ended with gmvh's answer chosen by Arnold
Corrected punctuation
Source Link
gmvh
  • 3.1k
  • 6
  • 27
  • 45

What is the best way to read advanced textbooks in Pure Mathematics  ( PhDPhD Level)?

This question was asked earlier on Mathstackexchange but was closed very very soon without any answer and then deleted by the system!

I am a PhD student ( 1st1st year) in a poor country with a corrupt academic system  ( veryvery nepotistic, racist,open bullying and other serious issues). So, a lot of mathematics I used to study was through textbooks of Western authors  ( SpringerSpringer, Wiley and others). Local textbooks are of poor quality. I had this question in mind for 4-5 years but I don't have any help of colleguescolleagues as everything is a competition in the country and I think this question should be asked to many people and also because I don't have much guidance in real life. Journey to even get admission in a PhD program was very hard due to racism, lack of guidance and personal issues. My specialization is Commutative Algebra. Most things I learnt was through self study only.

Question: What approach should I have while studying advanced mathematical textbooks (PhD level and beyond)?

My Approach: I start self studying from page 1 of chapter 1. Remember at the definitions and also the intuition. I go through statement of theorems and the proofs and see if I can understand the logic in the proofs. If I can then I go towards corollaries and next theorems and in the end I try to do 50% of the exercises at the chapter end. Then same happens in chapter 2 till the end of the book.

After some time I don't remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems as I don't try to memorize the crux ideas of the proof but always make sure that I can understand how the proof works in the book but I can remember definitions, statements of theorems and some corollaries.

What are the pitfalls in this approach? Do I need to remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems?

I shall be very grateful for any answer!

What is the best way to read advanced textbooks in Pure Mathematics( PhD Level)?

This question was asked earlier on Mathstackexchange but was closed very very soon without any answer and then deleted by the system!

I am a PhD student ( 1st year) in a poor country with a corrupt academic system( very nepotistic, racist,open bullying and other serious issues). So, a lot of mathematics I used to study was through textbooks of Western authors( Springer, Wiley and others). Local textbooks are of poor quality. I had this question in mind for 4-5 years but I don't have any help of collegues as everything is a competition in the country and I think this question should be asked to many people and also because I don't have much guidance in real life. Journey to even get admission in a PhD program was very hard due to racism, lack of guidance and personal issues. My specialization is Commutative Algebra. Most things I learnt was through self study only.

Question: What approach should I have while studying advanced mathematical textbooks (PhD level and beyond)?

My Approach: I start self studying from page 1 of chapter 1. Remember at the definitions and also the intuition. I go through statement of theorems and the proofs and see if I can understand the logic in the proofs. If I can then I go towards corollaries and next theorems and in the end I try to do 50% of the exercises at the chapter end. Then same happens in chapter 2 till the end of the book.

After some time I don't remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems as I don't try to memorize the crux ideas of the proof but always make sure that I can understand how the proof works in the book but I can remember definitions, statements of theorems and some corollaries.

What are the pitfalls in this approach? Do I need to remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems?

I shall be very grateful for any answer!

What is the best way to read advanced textbooks in Pure Mathematics  (PhD Level)?

This question was asked earlier on Mathstackexchange but was closed very very soon without any answer and then deleted by the system!

I am a PhD student (1st year) in a poor country with a corrupt academic system  (very nepotistic, racist,open bullying and other serious issues). So, a lot of mathematics I used to study was through textbooks of Western authors  (Springer, Wiley and others). Local textbooks are of poor quality. I had this question in mind for 4-5 years but I don't have any help of colleagues as everything is a competition in the country and I think this question should be asked to many people and also because I don't have much guidance in real life. Journey to even get admission in a PhD program was very hard due to racism, lack of guidance and personal issues. My specialization is Commutative Algebra. Most things I learnt was through self study only.

Question: What approach should I have while studying advanced mathematical textbooks (PhD level and beyond)?

My Approach: I start self studying from page 1 of chapter 1. Remember at the definitions and also the intuition. I go through statement of theorems and the proofs and see if I can understand the logic in the proofs. If I can then I go towards corollaries and next theorems and in the end I try to do 50% of the exercises at the chapter end. Then same happens in chapter 2 till the end of the book.

After some time I don't remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems as I don't try to memorize the crux ideas of the proof but always make sure that I can understand how the proof works in the book but I can remember definitions, statements of theorems and some corollaries.

What are the pitfalls in this approach? Do I need to remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems?

I shall be very grateful for any answer!

Notice added Improve details by Arnold
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Arnold
Source Link
Arnold
  • 793
  • 8
  • 23

What is the best way to read advanced textbooks in Pure Mathematics( PhD Level)?

This question was asked earlier on Mathstackexchange but was closed very very soon without any answer and then deleted by the system!

I am a PhD student ( 1st year) in a poor country with a corrupt academic system( very nepotistic, racist,open bullying and other serious issues). So, a lot of mathematics I used to study was through textbooks of Western authors( Springer, Wiley and others). Local textbooks are of poor quality. I had this question in mind for 4-5 years but I don't have any help of collegues as everything is a competition in the country and I think this question should be asked to many people and also because I don't have much guidance in real life. Journey to even get admission in a PhD program was very hard due to racism, lack of guidance and personal issues. My specialization is Commutative Algebra. Most things I learnt was through self study only.

Question: What approach should I have while studying advanced mathematical textbooks (PhD level and beyond)?

My Approach: I start self studying from page 1 of chapter 1. Remember at the definitions and also the intuition. I go through statement of theorems and the proofs and see if I can understand the logic in the proofs. If I can then I go towards corollaries and next theorems and in the end I try to do 50% of the exercises at the chapter end. Then same happens in chapter 2 till the end of the book.

After some time I don't remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems as I don't try to memorize the crux ideas of the proof but always make sure that I can understand how the proof works in the book but I can remember definitions, statements of theorems and some corollaries.

What are the pitfalls in this approach? Do I need to remember the core ideas of the proof of theorems?

I shall be very grateful for any answer!