Skip to main content
added 163 characters in body
Source Link
user369335
  • 696
  • 1
  • 5
  • 22

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known. So we only need to check $0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n$ one by one and make sure at least one instance exists. It is completely settled for small cases$n<196$, for examplehere is my result:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ $ 1 $
$4$ $ 0,4 $
$16$ $ 0,8,16 $
$36$ $ 0,12,24,36 $
$64$ $ 0,16,32,48,64 $
$100$$ 0,20,40,60,80,100 $
$144$$ 0,24,48,72,96,120,144 $

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ $ 1 $
$4$ $ 0,4 $
$16$ $ 0,8,16 $
$36$ $ 0,12,24,36 $
$64$ $ 0,16,32,48,64 $

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$. So we only need to check $0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n$ one by one and make sure at least one instance exists. It is completely settled for $n<196$, here is my result:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ $ 1 $
$4$ $ 0,4 $
$16$ $ 0,8,16 $
$36$ $ 0,12,24,36 $
$64$ $ 0,16,32,48,64 $
$100$$ 0,20,40,60,80,100 $
$144$$ 0,24,48,72,96,120,144 $
added 26 characters in body
Source Link
user369335
  • 696
  • 1
  • 5
  • 22

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ ${1}$$ 1 $
$4$ ${0,4}$$ 0,4 $
$16$ ${0,8,16}$$ 0,8,16 $
$36$ ${0,12,24,36}$$ 0,12,24,36 $
$64$$ 0,16,32,48,64 $

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ ${1}$
$4$ ${0,4}$
$16$ ${0,8,16}$
$36$ ${0,12,24,36}$

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ $ 1 $
$4$ $ 0,4 $
$16$ $ 0,8,16 $
$36$ $ 0,12,24,36 $
$64$$ 0,16,32,48,64 $
added 23 characters in body
Source Link
user369335
  • 696
  • 1
  • 5
  • 22

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ ${1}$
$4$ ${0,4}$
$16$ ${0,8,16}$
$36$${0,12,24,36}$

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ ${1}$
$4$ ${0,4}$
$16$ ${0,8,16}$

Currently, this is an open problem. So I only got a partial answer.

We just need to consider the following two different situations:

Case 1: $n$ is not a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \neq 0$; and $0$ is a possible choice for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$ if and only if symmetric HM conjecture is correct.

Case 2: $n$ is a perfect square. There is no solution if $\lvert trace(H) \rvert \notin \{0,2\sqrt{n},4\sqrt{n},...,n\}$; and all possible choices are known only for small cases, for example:

$n$ All possible choices for $\lvert trace(H) \rvert$
$1$ ${1}$
$4$ ${0,4}$
$16$ ${0,8,16}$
$36$${0,12,24,36}$
Source Link
user369335
  • 696
  • 1
  • 5
  • 22
Loading