Skip to main content
added 3 characters in body
Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement of $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $$F(x):=-\int_0^{-x} f(-t)\,dt$$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $$F(x):=-\int_0^{-x} f(-t)\,dt$$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement of $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $$F(x):=-\int_0^{-x} f(-t)\,dt$$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

added 22 characters in body
Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $F(x):=-F(-x)$ for $$F(x):=-\int_0^{-x} f(-t)\,dt$$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $F(x):=-F(-x)$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $$F(x):=-\int_0^{-x} f(-t)\,dt$$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$

Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

The answer is yes.

Indeed, in view of the possible replacement $f(x)$ by $\min(N,\max(-N,f(x))$ for an arbitrary real $N>0$ and all real $x$, assume without loss of generality that the function $f$ is bounded.

Let then $$F(x):=\int_0^x f(t)\,dt$$ for real $x\ge0$ and $F(x):=-F(-x)$ for real $x<0$. Then for all $d\in D$ and real $x\ge0$ $$F(x)=\int_0^x f(t+d)\,dt=F(x+d)-F(d),$$ so that $$F(x+d)=F(x)+F(d). \tag{1}\label{1}$$ Similarly, \eqref{1} holds for all real $x<0$ and all $d\in D$. Therefore and because $F$ is continuous, \eqref{1} holds for real $x$ and all real $d$. So, $F(x)=cx$ for some real $c$ and all real $x$. So, $f$, being an a.e. derivative of the absolutely continuous function $F$, equals $c$ a.e. $\quad\Box$