Skip to main content
`<strike>` was messing up the enumeration
Source Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69

So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

I want to:

  1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

  2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

 

     
  1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

  2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

  3. I am very happy with the answers and comments this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this as a useful exploration point.

    I assume Gourevitch's Conjecture remains open although if anyone had updates on it they could post here or this more trafficked location

    So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

    Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

    I want to:

    1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

    2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

     

    I am very happy with the answers and comments this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this as a useful exploration point.

    I assume Gourevitch's Conjecture remains open although if anyone had updates on it they could post here or this more trafficked location

    So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

    Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

    I want to: 

    1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

    2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

    3. I am very happy with the answers and comments this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this as a useful exploration point.

      I assume Gourevitch's Conjecture remains open although if anyone had updates on it they could post here or this more trafficked location

      spelling
      Link
      Daniel Asimov
      • 2.9k
      • 24
      • 26

      Does anyone remember what happened to the experimental search for polynomial identitesidentities for $\pi$?

      added 558 characters in body
      Source Link

      So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

      Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

      I want to:

      1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

      2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

      I am very happy with the answers and comments this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this as a useful exploration point.

      I assume Gourevitch's Conjecture remains open although if anyone had updates on it they could post here or this more trafficked location

      So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

      Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

      I want to:

      1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

      2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

      I am very happy with the answers this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this useful.

      So a while back I was on the internet and had encountered a website containing an experimental search for identities for $\pi$. My memory was that the page belonged to either Jonathan Sondow or Michael Somos, but now I am not sure (I don't even know if I trust my memory on the 'S' in the last name) . The page most likely belongs to Jim Cullen and I have been wrongly attributing the open status of these identities to Gourevitch's conjecture (special thanks to Timothy Chow for reverse-engineering my brain and revealing this very unfortunate mental hash collision).

      Basically they had experimentally searched the space of identities of the form $\sum_{n=0}^{\infty} \frac{1}{P(n)}$ over a large number of polynomials $P(n)$ and used a tool like Munafo's RIES to see if they matched any known forms. They had struck gold finding some unusual identities involving either $\pi^2$ or $\pi^4$ with quadratic or quartic denominators (I don't remember which). These identities looked like they should be related to the riemann zeta function but the identities had no known proof/explanation at the time.

      I want to:

      1. find this website so at least I can edit this question and give the person due credit.

      2. Ask what the state of those identities are. Do they remain open?

      I am very happy with the answers and comments this question has generated. I think other people interested in $\pi$ formulas will probably find this as a useful exploration point.

      I assume Gourevitch's Conjecture remains open although if anyone had updates on it they could post here or this more trafficked location

      added 558 characters in body
      Source Link
      Loading
      added 106 characters in body
      Source Link
      Loading
      Source Link
      Loading