Skip to main content

Here's a reduction to the finite dimensional case. Let F$F$ be a finite set of subspaces of X$X$. For each finite dimensional subspace Y$Y$ of X$X$, let u(Y)$u(Y)$ be the set of elements Z$Z$ of F$F$ such that Y$Y$ is contained in Z$Z$. By assumption, u(Y)$u(Y)$ is non-empty for every Y$Y$. Since any two finite dimensional subspaces are contained in a third, the intersection of the sets u(Y)$u(Y)$, as Y$Y$ runs among all finite dimensional subspaces of X$X$, is non-empty. Hence there is at least one set in F$F$ that contains every finite dimensional subspace of X$X$, hence contains X$X$.

For the finite dimensional case, let F$F$ be a finite set of subspaces of X$X$. By induction, every codimension 1 subspace of X$X$ is contained in some Y$Y$ from F$F$. But there are infinitely many codimension 1$1$ subspaces, so some Y$Y$ in F$F$ contains more than one such subspace. Any two distinct codimension 1 subspaces span X$\operatorname{span} X$ (if dim X > 1$\dim X > 1$) so Y = X$Y = X$.

Here's a reduction to the finite dimensional case. Let F be a finite set of subspaces of X. For each finite dimensional subspace Y of X, let u(Y) be the set of elements Z of F such that Y is contained in Z. By assumption, u(Y) is non-empty for every Y. Since any two finite dimensional subspaces are contained in a third, the intersection of the sets u(Y), as Y runs among all finite dimensional subspaces of X, is non-empty. Hence there is at least one set in F that contains every finite dimensional subspace of X, hence contains X.

For the finite dimensional case, let F be a finite set of subspaces of X. By induction, every codimension 1 subspace of X is contained in some Y from F. But there are infinitely many codimension 1 subspaces, so some Y in F contains more than one such subspace. Any two distinct codimension 1 subspaces span X (if dim X > 1) so Y = X.

Here's a reduction to the finite dimensional case. Let $F$ be a finite set of subspaces of $X$. For each finite dimensional subspace $Y$ of $X$, let $u(Y)$ be the set of elements $Z$ of $F$ such that $Y$ is contained in $Z$. By assumption, $u(Y)$ is non-empty for every $Y$. Since any two finite dimensional subspaces are contained in a third, the intersection of the sets $u(Y)$, as $Y$ runs among all finite dimensional subspaces of $X$, is non-empty. Hence there is at least one set in $F$ that contains every finite dimensional subspace of $X$, hence contains $X$.

For the finite dimensional case, let $F$ be a finite set of subspaces of $X$. By induction, every codimension 1 subspace of $X$ is contained in some $Y$ from $F$. But there are infinitely many codimension $1$ subspaces, so some $Y$ in $F$ contains more than one such subspace. Any two distinct codimension 1 subspaces $\operatorname{span} X$ (if $\dim X > 1$) so $Y = X$.

Source Link
Jonathan Wise
  • 8k
  • 1
  • 47
  • 53

Here's a reduction to the finite dimensional case. Let F be a finite set of subspaces of X. For each finite dimensional subspace Y of X, let u(Y) be the set of elements Z of F such that Y is contained in Z. By assumption, u(Y) is non-empty for every Y. Since any two finite dimensional subspaces are contained in a third, the intersection of the sets u(Y), as Y runs among all finite dimensional subspaces of X, is non-empty. Hence there is at least one set in F that contains every finite dimensional subspace of X, hence contains X.

For the finite dimensional case, let F be a finite set of subspaces of X. By induction, every codimension 1 subspace of X is contained in some Y from F. But there are infinitely many codimension 1 subspaces, so some Y in F contains more than one such subspace. Any two distinct codimension 1 subspaces span X (if dim X > 1) so Y = X.