Skip to main content
15 events
when toggle format what by license comment
Mar 23 at 13:43 vote accept Andrea Aveni
Mar 19 at 11:41 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
clarifications
Mar 19 at 11:27 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
added thoughts on other finite maximal subgroups
Mar 17 at 19:42 comment added Geoff Robinson @YCor : Great. I think the statement in my answer about the hyperoctahedral group being maximal finite of maximal order will not be true in some small cases, (some larger than five, I think).
Mar 17 at 19:01 comment added YCor @GeoffRobinson I have checked that it's maximal-finite for for all $n\ge 5$ (and thus it's not only for $n=2,4$). Details are a bit lengthy; these are mostly inequalities. No contradiction with $E_8$: the latter root system is invariant not under the full $\pm 1$-monomial group of order $2^8.8!$, but under its "'usual" index 2 subgroup.
Mar 16 at 16:33 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
typo
Mar 16 at 16:12 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
clarified
Mar 16 at 13:36 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
clarification
Mar 16 at 13:11 history edited Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0
Roughly sketched justification of claim from Collins's Jordan's theorem result.
Mar 16 at 12:27 comment added Geoff Robinson It won't be unique, I think, but it will be of maximal possible order subject to being finite maximal in ${\rm O}_{n}(\mathbb{R})$ (for large enough $n$), and it will be unique one of that largest order.
Mar 16 at 11:07 comment added Andrea Aveni Thank you, I found the article and it seems related (even though I don't quite yet see how to derive your claim from it). Do you think that the hyperoctahedral group is the unique finite-maximal subgroup of $\mathrm{O}_n(\mathbb R)$ for $n$ sufficiently large?
Mar 16 at 10:53 comment added Geoff Robinson @YCor : Thanks, I had forgotten that question/answer.
Mar 16 at 10:02 comment added YCor This is close to mathoverflow.net/questions/422947
Mar 16 at 8:22 comment added YCor I'd guess it's true for all $n\ge 5$.
Mar 16 at 7:52 history answered Geoff Robinson CC BY-SA 4.0