Skip to main content
8 events
when toggle format what by license comment
Jan 20 at 23:51 comment added Andrea Marino Of course, you are right. I am quite convinced that there is an error somewhere: the adjustment I made of my 'typo' is partial and should be revisited more thoroughly. The devil is in the details...
Jan 19 at 21:56 comment added Blazej A short exact sequence $0 \to A \to B \to C \to 0$ with $C$ free splits, so $B \cong A \oplus C$. I will rethink your counterexample with the typo corrected later.
Jan 19 at 18:58 comment added Andrea Marino Yes, you are right: I forgot a -1. I was identifying $x^km$ with $m$, which corresponds of course to quotienting by $x^k-1$. Why do you claim that an extension of free modules by a free module is free? It seems like mine is a counterexample, but maybe you have a simple homological proof in mind, and that's why you are puzzled by my calculation.
Jan 19 at 18:53 history edited Andrea Marino CC BY-SA 4.0
added 24 characters in body
Jan 19 at 16:48 comment added Blazej Unless I am screwing something up, there can't be a counter-example for prime $n$. Then quasi-free is equivalent to free, and an extension of a free module by a free module is free. Characterization of free modules in homological terms is given by the (positive resolution of) Serre's "conjecture".
Jan 19 at 16:40 comment added Blazej I am a bit confused by the part titled "Observation". $x$ is an invertible element of the ring, so $M/(x^k M)=0$.
Jan 1 at 20:24 history edited Andrea Marino CC BY-SA 4.0
added 158 characters in body
Jan 1 at 19:47 history answered Andrea Marino CC BY-SA 4.0