Skip to main content
Post Closed as "Not suitable for this site" by Max Horn, Arturo Magidin, Gerry Myerson, LSpice, Yemon Choi
copied question to body
Source Link
YCor
  • 63.9k
  • 5
  • 187
  • 286

Prove that every group $G$ with $p^n$ ($n\ge4$) elements and center with $p$ elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove what I've written in the titleabove assertion. I've already proven that every such $G$ has an element $x$ whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on $n$. I proved the case $n=4$ where the group of order $p^3$ is the centralizer of one of the elements. Then supposing it is true for $n=k$ I want to prove it for $n=k+1$. I know once again that $G$ contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have $p$ elements in the center since there are at least $p+1$ elements in it (the element itself and the center of $G$ which has $p$ elements) and so I can't apply the induction. I'm sorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion I would be really grateful. Thank you in advance.

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove what I've written in the title. I've already proven that every such $G$ has an element $x$ whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on $n$. I proved the case $n=4$ where the group of order $p^3$ is the centralizer of one of the elements. Then supposing it is true for $n=k$ I want to prove it for $n=k+1$. I know once again that $G$ contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have $p$ elements in the center since there are at least $p+1$ elements in it (the element itself and the center of $G$ which has $p$ elements) and so I can't apply the induction. I'm sorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion I would be really grateful. Thank you in advance.

Prove that every group $G$ with $p^n$ ($n\ge4$) elements and center with $p$ elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove the above assertion. I've already proven that every such $G$ has an element $x$ whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on $n$. I proved the case $n=4$ where the group of order $p^3$ is the centralizer of one of the elements. Then supposing it is true for $n=k$ I want to prove it for $n=k+1$. I know once again that $G$ contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have $p$ elements in the center since there are at least $p+1$ elements in it (the element itself and the center of $G$ which has $p$ elements) and so I can't apply the induction. I'm sorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion I would be really grateful. Thank you in advance.

Math in title
Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69

Prove that every group G$G$ with $p^n$ (n$\ge$4$n\ge4$) elements and center with $p$ elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

added 21 characters in body; edited title
Source Link
Max Horn
  • 5.7k
  • 3
  • 33
  • 50

Prove that every group G with $p^n$ (n$\ge$4)elements elements and center with p$p$ elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove what I've written in the title. I've already proven that every such G$G$ has an element x$x$ whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on n$n$. I proved the case n=4$n=4$ where the group of order $p^3$ Isis the centralizer of Oneone of the elements. Then supposing It Isit is true for n=k$n=k$ I want to prove Itit for n=k+1$n=k+1$. I know once again that G$G$ contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have p$p$ elements in the center since there are at least p+1$p+1$ elements in Itit (the element itself and the center of G$G$ which has p$p$ elements) and so iI can't apply the induction. I'm Sorrysorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion iI would be really grateful.Thank Thank you in advance.

Prove that every group G with $p^n$ (n$\ge$4)elements and center with p elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove what I've written in the title. I've already proven that every such G has an element x whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on n. I proved the case n=4 where the group of order $p^3$ Is the centralizer of One of the elements. Then supposing It Is true for n=k I want to prove It for n=k+1. I know once again that G contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have p elements in the center since there are at least p+1 elements in It (the element itself and the center of G which has p elements) and so i can't apply the induction. I'm Sorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion i would be really grateful.Thank you in advance.

Prove that every group G with $p^n$ (n$\ge$4) elements and center with $p$ elements has an abelian subgroup of order $p^3$

I'm new in this forum so I hope I haven't made any mistake. I have to prove what I've written in the title. I've already proven that every such $G$ has an element $x$ whose centralizer has $p^{n-1}$ elements. I tried to prove it by induction on $n$. I proved the case $n=4$ where the group of order $p^3$ is the centralizer of one of the elements. Then supposing it is true for $n=k$ I want to prove it for $n=k+1$. I know once again that $G$ contains an element whose centralizer has $p^{k+1-1}=p^k$ elements. However this subgroup obviously doesn't have $p$ elements in the center since there are at least $p+1$ elements in it (the element itself and the center of $G$ which has $p$ elements) and so I can't apply the induction. I'm sorry for my English also, it's not my first language. If anybody has any suggestion I would be really grateful. Thank you in advance.

edited body
Source Link
Loading
edited title
Link
Loading
edited title
Link
Loading
edited title
Link
Loading
edited title
Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading