Skip to main content
edited title
Link

Math reviews in Examples of ZBMath reviews that motivated you to read the paper

Post Made Community Wiki by Asaf Karagila
tags
Link
Wojowu
  • 28.2k
  • 3
  • 103
  • 185
Source Link

Math reviews in ZBMath that motivated you to read the paper

This is community wiki question.

I will be writing my first review for ZBMath. I would like to take some suggestion through examples.

In general, abstract is too small and introduction is too lengthy in a paper to decide whether to read the paper or not.

I am under the impression that an ideal review for a (published) article should be more like an invitation from the referee to the user to read the paper, or, much better to be an appreciation letter.

Question : Are there any reviews in ZBMath (Mathscinet has restricted access) that motivated you to read the article. Can you give some examples.

I am aware of the question How to write a good MathSciNet review?. That discusses theoretical aspect of a good review but it not all of the answers have examples showing a good review.