Skip to main content
clean up unnecessary details and focus on asking the question
Source Link

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.


 

EDIT 1: As pointed out in the comments, this map has fibers which are tori over a generic point, and some of those tori are replaced by circles when the coordinates are 0 (or perhaps 1).

Thus, $f$ is a singular toric fibration. Is it possible to apply a modified Serre spectral sequence to compute the cohomology?

It has been shown by myself and Stephen Rosenberg that the cohomology of the base space is trivial here with code on GitHub.


EDIT 2: Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. Claim: $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial. $H^*(Y_n)$ sits in $H^*(X_N)$ as an invariant subspace, since $X_N \rightarrow Y_n$ as $\Sigma_n \subset \Sigma_N$ and $H^*$ is a contravariant functor. Note that $X_N$ is a symmetric space. $H^*(\mathbb{S}^3)$ is non-trivial, so we expect $H^*(X_N)$ to be nontrivial.


EDIT 3: Note that $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N \cong P^N$ by mapping inhomogeneous coordinates $(Z_1,...,Z_N)$ to coefficients of the symmetric polynomial $(x-Z_1)...(x-Z_N)$. $(S^3)^N/\Sigma_N$ has a $T^N$ fibration over $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N$ by Hopf $S^3 \rightarrow P^1$. Then there is a spectral sequence on this fiber bundle. The $E_2$ pageWhat is the tensor product between $H^*(\text{base}=P^N)$ and $H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$. So $H^*((S^3)^N/\Sigma_N)$ has dim. not greater than dim. $$H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$$


Acknowledgements: Thank you to Siu-Cheong Lau for helpful comments.$H^*(Y_n;\mathbb{Z})$?

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.


 

EDIT 1: As pointed out in the comments, this map has fibers which are tori over a generic point, and some of those tori are replaced by circles when the coordinates are 0 (or perhaps 1).

Thus, $f$ is a singular toric fibration. Is it possible to apply a modified Serre spectral sequence to compute the cohomology?

It has been shown by myself and Stephen Rosenberg that the cohomology of the base space is trivial here with code on GitHub.


EDIT 2: Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. Claim: $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial. $H^*(Y_n)$ sits in $H^*(X_N)$ as an invariant subspace, since $X_N \rightarrow Y_n$ as $\Sigma_n \subset \Sigma_N$ and $H^*$ is a contravariant functor. Note that $X_N$ is a symmetric space. $H^*(\mathbb{S}^3)$ is non-trivial, so we expect $H^*(X_N)$ to be nontrivial.


EDIT 3: Note that $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N \cong P^N$ by mapping inhomogeneous coordinates $(Z_1,...,Z_N)$ to coefficients of the symmetric polynomial $(x-Z_1)...(x-Z_N)$. $(S^3)^N/\Sigma_N$ has a $T^N$ fibration over $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N$ by Hopf $S^3 \rightarrow P^1$. Then there is a spectral sequence on this fiber bundle. The $E_2$ page is the tensor product between $H^*(\text{base}=P^N)$ and $H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$. So $H^*((S^3)^N/\Sigma_N)$ has dim. not greater than dim. $$H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$$


Acknowledgements: Thank you to Siu-Cheong Lau for helpful comments.

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.

Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. What is $H^*(Y_n;\mathbb{Z})$?

Notice removed Authoritative reference needed by Jackson Walters
Bounty Ended with Ian Agol's answer chosen by Jackson Walters
updated title to better reflect what is being computed
Link

Cohomology of a (singular) fibration over the moduliamplitude space of unlabeled quantum networks

formatting for last part
Source Link

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.


EDIT 1: As pointed out in the comments, this map has fibers which are tori over a generic point, and some of those tori are replaced by circles when the coordinates are 0 (or perhaps 1).

Thus, $f$ is a singular toric fibration. Is it possible to apply a modified Serre spectral sequence to compute the cohomology?

It has been shown by myself and Stephen Rosenberg that the cohomology of the base space is trivial here with code on GitHub.


EDIT 2: Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. Claim: $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial. $H^*(X_N)$$H^*(Y_n)$ sits in $H^*(Y_n)$$H^*(X_N)$ as an invariant subspace, since $Y_n \rightarrow X_N$$X_N \rightarrow Y_n$ as $\Sigma_n \subset \Sigma_N$ and $H^*$ is a contravariant functor. Note that $X_N$ is a symmetric space. $H^*(\mathbb{S}^3)$ is non-trivial, so we expect $H^*(X_N)$ to be nontrivial.


ChatGPT gives a helpful outline of how to compute $H^*(X_N)$ when $N=4$, noting that $H^*(S^3)=\mathbb{R}[1,x]$, with 1 in degree 0 and $x$ in degree 3. $H^*((S^3)^4)=\mathbb{R}[1,x]^{\otimes 4}$. Then it states "the action of $\Sigma_4$ will induce certain relations in the cohomology", and suggest using tools from equivariant cohomology and representation theory.


EDIT 3: From Siu-Cheong: Note that $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N \cong P^N$ by mapping inhomogeneous coordinates $(Z_1,...,Z_N)$ to coefficients of the symmetric polynomial $(x-Z_1)...(x-Z_N)$. $(S^3)^N/\Sigma_N$ has a $T^N$ fibration over $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N$ by Hopf $S^3 \rightarrow P^1$. Then there is a spectral sequence on this fiber bundle. The $E_2$ page is the tensor product between $H^*(\text{base}=P^N)$ and $H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$. So $H^*((S^3)^N/\Sigma_N)$ has dim. not greater than $H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$dim. $$H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$$


Acknowledgements: Thank you to Siu-Cheong Lau for helpful comments.

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.


EDIT 1: As pointed out in the comments, this map has fibers which are tori over a generic point, and some of those tori are replaced by circles when the coordinates are 0 (or perhaps 1).

Thus, $f$ is a singular toric fibration. Is it possible to apply a modified Serre spectral sequence to compute the cohomology?

It has been shown by myself and Stephen Rosenberg that the cohomology of the base space is trivial here with code on GitHub.


EDIT 2: Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. Claim: $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial. $H^*(X_N)$ sits in $H^*(Y_n)$ as an invariant subspace, since $Y_n \rightarrow X_N$ as $\Sigma_n \subset \Sigma_N$ and $H^*$ is a contravariant functor. Note that $X_N$ is a symmetric space. $H^*(\mathbb{S}^3)$ is non-trivial, so we expect $H^*(X_N)$ to be nontrivial.


ChatGPT gives a helpful outline of how to compute $H^*(X_N)$ when $N=4$, noting that $H^*(S^3)=\mathbb{R}[1,x]$, with 1 in degree 0 and $x$ in degree 3. $H^*((S^3)^4)=\mathbb{R}[1,x]^{\otimes 4}$. Then it states "the action of $\Sigma_4$ will induce certain relations in the cohomology", and suggest using tools from equivariant cohomology and representation theory.


EDIT 3: From Siu-Cheong: Note that $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N \cong P^N$ by mapping inhomogeneous coordinates $(Z_1,...,Z_N)$ to coefficients of the symmetric polynomial $(x-Z_1)...(x-Z_N)$. $(S^3)^N/\Sigma_N$ has a $T^N$ fibration over $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N$ by Hopf $S^3 \rightarrow P^1$. Then there is a spectral sequence on this fiber bundle. The $E_2$ page is the tensor product between $H^*(\text{base}=P^N)$ and $H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$. So $H^*((S^3)^N/\Sigma_N)$ has dim. not greater than $H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$.


Acknowledgements: Thank you to Siu-Cheong Lau for helpful comments.

I am investigating a particular map from a product of three-spheres to the moduli space of (non-negative, real edge weight) networks. The map in question is

$$f: \smash{\left( \mathbb{S}^3 \right)}^N \rightarrow \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N$$

where $N=\binom{n}{2}$ is the number of edges of a complete graph. We are placing a qubit on each edge of the underlying graph, given by $g: \mathbb{R}_{\ge 0}^N \rightarrow \{0,1\}^N$, a semi-ring morphism.

A qubit lives in the Bloch sphere, $\mathbb{S}^3$. Define $e_{ij}:=e_{ij}^0 \lvert0\rangle + e_{ij}^1 \rvert1\rangle$, with $\lvert e_{ij}^0\rvert^2 + \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2 = 1$, and $e_{ij}^k \in \mathbb{C}$. $f$ is given by applying $e_{ij} \rightarrow \lvert e_{ij}^1\rvert^2$ for $1 \le i < j \le n$.

To get unlabeled networks, quotient by the permutation group $\Sigma_n$ where $\sigma \cdot e_{ij} = e_{\sigma(i)\sigma(j)}$.


EDIT 1: As pointed out in the comments, this map has fibers which are tori over a generic point, and some of those tori are replaced by circles when the coordinates are 0 (or perhaps 1).

Thus, $f$ is a singular toric fibration. Is it possible to apply a modified Serre spectral sequence to compute the cohomology?

It has been shown by myself and Stephen Rosenberg that the cohomology of the base space is trivial here with code on GitHub.


EDIT 2: Let $Y_n=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N / \Sigma_n$ and $X_N=(\mathbb{S}^3)^N/\Sigma_N$. Claim: $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial. $H^*(Y_n)$ sits in $H^*(X_N)$ as an invariant subspace, since $X_N \rightarrow Y_n$ as $\Sigma_n \subset \Sigma_N$ and $H^*$ is a contravariant functor. Note that $X_N$ is a symmetric space. $H^*(\mathbb{S}^3)$ is non-trivial, so we expect $H^*(X_N)$ to be nontrivial.


EDIT 3: Note that $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N \cong P^N$ by mapping inhomogeneous coordinates $(Z_1,...,Z_N)$ to coefficients of the symmetric polynomial $(x-Z_1)...(x-Z_N)$. $(S^3)^N/\Sigma_N$ has a $T^N$ fibration over $(P^1)^N/\Sigma_N$ by Hopf $S^3 \rightarrow P^1$. Then there is a spectral sequence on this fiber bundle. The $E_2$ page is the tensor product between $H^*(\text{base}=P^N)$ and $H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$. So $H^*((S^3)^N/\Sigma_N)$ has dim. not greater than dim. $$H^*(\text{base}=P^N) \otimes H^*(\text{fiber}=T^N)$$


Acknowledgements: Thank you to Siu-Cheong Lau for helpful comments.

use \text
Source Link
Loading
deleted ChatGPT's attempt at computing H^*(Y_n)
Source Link
Loading
compressed ChatGPT responses to text from images. added Siu-Cheong's comments
Source Link
Loading
just give the outline until an authoritative response from a mathematician or software package is given
Source Link
Loading
add ChatGPT disclaimer and update computation to show results for \mathbb{Z} coefficients
Source Link
Loading
ChatGPT claims to compute the cohomology of X_N when N=4 with coefficients in R
Source Link
Loading
changed notation to X_N and Y_n since using Y_N is confusing. edited ChatGPT's response.
Source Link
Loading
$Y_N$ is a connected space so $H^0(Y_N)=\mathbb{Z}$. ChatGPT has made an obvious error.
Source Link
Loading
add result for n=4, N=6
Source Link
Loading
add computation showing $H^*(Y_n)$ is non-trivial
Source Link
Loading
Notice added Authoritative reference needed by Jackson Walters
Bounty Started worth 50 reputation by Jackson Walters
incorporate comment and suggest computation involving modified Serre spectral sequence
Source Link
Loading
Capitalise title
Source Link
LSpice
  • 12.9k
  • 4
  • 45
  • 69
Loading
we are interested in unlabeled networks
Source Link
Loading
Source Link
Loading