Skip to main content
added 50 characters in body
Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

Yes (mainly). That $u_*:=1_{f<0}$ is a minimizer (of $\int uf$ over all $u\in X(\Omega)$) follows because, if $0\le u\le1$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0, \tag{1}\label{1}$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though. If $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ and $u_{**}=u_*$ almost everywhere (a.e.) on the set $[f\ne0]:=\{x\colon f(x)\ne0\}$, then $\int u_{**}f=\int u_*f$, so that $u_{**}$ is also a minimizer. Vice versa, if $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer, then, by \eqref{1}, $$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=0,$$$$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=\int u_{**}\,f-\int u_*\,f=0,$$ so that $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$. Thus, $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer if and only if $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$.


The same conclusion holds with $\{v\in L^2(\Omega)\colon v(x)\in[0,1] \ \forall x\in\Omega\}$ in place of $X(\Omega)=\{v\in L^2(\Omega)\colon v(x)\in\{0,1\} \ \forall x\in\Omega\}$.

Yes (mainly). That $u_*:=1_{f<0}$ is a minimizer (of $\int uf$ over all $u\in X(\Omega)$) follows because, if $0\le u\le1$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0, \tag{1}\label{1}$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though. If $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ and $u_{**}=u_*$ almost everywhere (a.e.) on the set $[f\ne0]:=\{x\colon f(x)\ne0\}$, then $\int u_{**}f=\int u_*f$, so that $u_{**}$ is also a minimizer. Vice versa, if $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer, then, by \eqref{1}, $$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=0,$$ so that $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$. Thus, $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer if and only if $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$.

Yes (mainly). That $u_*:=1_{f<0}$ is a minimizer (of $\int uf$ over all $u\in X(\Omega)$) follows because, if $0\le u\le1$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0, \tag{1}\label{1}$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though. If $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ and $u_{**}=u_*$ almost everywhere (a.e.) on the set $[f\ne0]:=\{x\colon f(x)\ne0\}$, then $\int u_{**}f=\int u_*f$, so that $u_{**}$ is also a minimizer. Vice versa, if $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer, then, by \eqref{1}, $$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=\int u_{**}\,f-\int u_*\,f=0,$$ so that $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$. Thus, $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer if and only if $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$.


The same conclusion holds with $\{v\in L^2(\Omega)\colon v(x)\in[0,1] \ \forall x\in\Omega\}$ in place of $X(\Omega)=\{v\in L^2(\Omega)\colon v(x)\in\{0,1\} \ \forall x\in\Omega\}$.

added 50 characters in body
Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

Yes (mainly). ThisThat $u_*:=1_{f<0}$ is a minimizer (of $\int uf$ over all $u\in X(\Omega)$) follows because, if $0\le u\le1$ and $u_*:=1_{f<0}$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0,$$$$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0, \tag{1}\label{1}$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though. If $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ and $u_{**}=u_*$ almost everywhere (a.e.) on the set $[f\ne0]:=\{x\colon f(x)\ne0\}$, then $\int u_{**}f=\int u_*f$, so that $u_{**}$ is also a minimizer. Vice versa, if $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer, then, by \eqref{1}, $$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=0,$$ so that $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$. Thus, $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer if and only if $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$.

Yes (mainly). This follows because, if $0\le u\le1$ and $u_*:=1_{f<0}$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0,$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though.

Yes (mainly). That $u_*:=1_{f<0}$ is a minimizer (of $\int uf$ over all $u\in X(\Omega)$) follows because, if $0\le u\le1$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0, \tag{1}\label{1}$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though. If $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ and $u_{**}=u_*$ almost everywhere (a.e.) on the set $[f\ne0]:=\{x\colon f(x)\ne0\}$, then $\int u_{**}f=\int u_*f$, so that $u_{**}$ is also a minimizer. Vice versa, if $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer, then, by \eqref{1}, $$\int|u_{**}-u_*|\,|f|=\int(u_{**}-u_*)\,f=0,$$ so that $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$. Thus, $u_{**}\in X(\Omega)$ is a minimizer if and only if $u_{**}=u_*$ a.e. on the set $[f\ne0]$.

added 50 characters in body
Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229

Yes (mainly). This follows because, if $0\le u\le1$ and $u_*:=1_{f<0}$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0,$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though.

Yes. This follows because, if $0\le u\le1$ and $u_*:=1_{f<0}$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0,$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

Yes (mainly). This follows because, if $0\le u\le1$ and $u_*:=1_{f<0}$, then $$uf-u_*f=(u-u_*)f\ge0,$$ whence $$\int u_*f\le\int uf.$$

The minimizer is not unique, though.

Source Link
Iosif Pinelis
  • 127.7k
  • 8
  • 107
  • 229
Loading