Skip to main content
Adjusted color on diagram, just to make it look nicer.
Source Link

The following seems like a counterexample to the conjecture as originally stated, allowing different size coins. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.) (I haven't done "formal" algebra to verify this, but just looking at it, it seems to be so.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description hereenter image description here

The following seems like a counterexample to the conjecture as originally stated, allowing different size coins. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.) (I haven't done "formal" algebra to verify this, but just looking at it, it seems to be so.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

The following seems like a counterexample to the conjecture as originally stated, allowing different size coins. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.) (I haven't done "formal" algebra to verify this, but just looking at it, it seems to be so.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

added 137 characters in body
Source Link
Zach Teitler
  • 6.2k
  • 3
  • 33
  • 63

I'm not sure if this isThe following seems like a counterexample to the conjecture as originally stated, but I think it might beallowing different size coins. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.) (I haven't done "formal" algebra to verify this, but just looking at it, it seems to be so.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

I'm not sure if this is a counterexample, but I think it might be. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

The following seems like a counterexample to the conjecture as originally stated, allowing different size coins. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.) (I haven't done "formal" algebra to verify this, but just looking at it, it seems to be so.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

Providing a digitally-made version of Zach Teitler's idea.
Source Link

I'm not sure if this is a counterexample, but I think it might be. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

I'm not sure if this is a counterexample, but I think it might be. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.)

square with big coin and four small coins

I'm not sure if this is a counterexample, but I think it might be. It doesn't seem like the big coin, with diameter $1-\epsilon$, can move right, up, or down. (I apologize for the poor drawing.)

square with big coin and four small coins

Edit by OP: Here's another look at your idea.

enter image description here

I wrote left but I meant right.
Source Link
Zach Teitler
  • 6.2k
  • 3
  • 33
  • 63
Loading
Source Link
Zach Teitler
  • 6.2k
  • 3
  • 33
  • 63
Loading