Skip to main content

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p$p$ be a fixed prime, c$c$ a fixed positive real parameter and n$n$ a large number. Consider a random (0,1)$(0,1)$ matrix with entries in Z/p$Z/p$, where the probability of a 0$0$ is 1-c/n$1-\frac{c}{n}$ and that of a 1$1$ is c/n$\frac{c}{n}$. As n--> infty$n\rightarrow \infty$, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? UPDATE: As moonface points out, this probability is 1$1$. Furthermore, his argument points out that we should expect the corank to be something like a*n$a*n$. So I'll ask more generally what we can say about the behavior of the rank as n -> infty$n\rightarrow\infty$.

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if this point would strongly effect your answer.

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p be a fixed prime, c a fixed positive real parameter and n a large number. Consider a random (0,1) matrix with entries in Z/p, where the probability of a 0 is 1-c/n and that of a 1 is c/n. As n--> infty, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? UPDATE: As moonface points out, this probability is 1. Furthermore, his argument points out that we should expect the corank to be something like a*n. So I'll ask more generally what we can say about the behavior of the rank as n -> infty.

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if this point would strongly effect your answer.

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let $p$ be a fixed prime, $c$ a fixed positive real parameter and $n$ a large number. Consider a random $(0,1)$ matrix with entries in $Z/p$, where the probability of a $0$ is $1-\frac{c}{n}$ and that of a $1$ is $\frac{c}{n}$. As $n\rightarrow \infty$, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? UPDATE: As moonface points out, this probability is $1$. Furthermore, his argument points out that we should expect the corank to be something like $a*n$. So I'll ask more generally what we can say about the behavior of the rank as $n\rightarrow\infty$.

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if this point would strongly effect your answer.

added 134 characters in body
Source Link
David E Speyer
  • 156.3k
  • 14
  • 422
  • 763

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p be a fixed prime, c a fixed positive real parameter and n a large number. Consider a random (0,1) matrix with entries in Z/p, where the probability of a 0 is 1-c/n and that of a 1 is c/n. As n--> infty, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? WhatUPDATE: As moonface points out, this probability is 1. Furthermore, his argument points out that we should expect the corank to be something like a*n. So I'll ask more generally what we can you say about the probability distributionbehavior of itsthe rank? as n -> infty.

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if a small number of entries with a different distributionthis point would strongly effect your answer.

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p be a fixed prime, c a fixed positive real parameter and n a large number. Consider a random (0,1) matrix with entries in Z/p, where the probability of a 0 is 1-c/n and that of a 1 is c/n. As n--> infty, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? What can you say about the probability distribution of its rank?

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if a small number of entries with a different distribution would strongly effect your answer.

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p be a fixed prime, c a fixed positive real parameter and n a large number. Consider a random (0,1) matrix with entries in Z/p, where the probability of a 0 is 1-c/n and that of a 1 is c/n. As n--> infty, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? UPDATE: As moonface points out, this probability is 1. Furthermore, his argument points out that we should expect the corank to be something like a*n. So I'll ask more generally what we can say about the behavior of the rank as n -> infty.

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if this point would strongly effect your answer.

Source Link
David E Speyer
  • 156.3k
  • 14
  • 422
  • 763

Singularity of sparse random matrices

The following topic came up in conversation with my office-mate Lionel: Let p be a fixed prime, c a fixed positive real parameter and n a large number. Consider a random (0,1) matrix with entries in Z/p, where the probability of a 0 is 1-c/n and that of a 1 is c/n. As n--> infty, what is the probability that this matrix is singular? What can you say about the probability distribution of its rank?

Actually, in our motivating example, the matrix is symmetric and the distribution on the diagonal is different than in the rest of the matrix. I left these details out, but please mention it if a small number of entries with a different distribution would strongly effect your answer.