Skip to main content
Rollback to Revision 1
Source Link
Georges Elencwajg
  • 47.5k
  • 14
  • 159
  • 241

Here is anotherthe great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:

Let
Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology classclas and denotedefine $[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$(no choice here!) $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied becausesince all intersections $U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$$U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ because since the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which can'tdoes not restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Here is another great answer given by another of my friends:

Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology class and denote $[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied because all intersections $U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ because the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which can't restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.

Here is the great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:
Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology clas and define (no choice here!) $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied since all intersections $U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ since the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which does not restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Rollback to Revision 2
Source Link
Georges Elencwajg
  • 47.5k
  • 14
  • 159
  • 241

Here is theanother great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:
Let

Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology clasclass and define (no choice here!)denote $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$$[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied sincebecause all intersections $U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$$U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ since because the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which does notcan't restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Here is the great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:
Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology clas and define (no choice here!) $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied since all intersections $U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ since the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which does not restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Here is another great answer given by another of my friends:

Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology class and denote $[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied because all intersections $U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ because the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which can't restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.

Rollback to Revision 1
Source Link
Georges Elencwajg
  • 47.5k
  • 14
  • 159
  • 241

Here is anotherthe great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:

Let
Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology classclas and denotedefine $[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$(no choice here!) $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied becausesince all intersections $U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$$U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ because since the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which can'tdoes not restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Here is another great answer given by another of my friends:

Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology class and denote $[\omega_i]=0\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied because all intersections $U_i\cap U_j$ for $i\neq j$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ because the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which can't restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.

Here is the great answer given by another of my brilliant friends:
Let $X$ be $\mathbb C, U_0$ be the open complement in $X$ of the closed disk $\bar D=\{z\in \mathbb C\vert \vert z\vert \leq1 \}$ and add a few open discs $U_1,\cdots, U_n$ of radius $\lt 1$ covering $\bar D$ in order to obtain an open covering $U_0,U_1,\cdots U_n$ of $X$.
Now let $[0]\neq[\omega _0]\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)\cong \mathbb Z$ be a nonzero cohomology clas and define (no choice here!) $0=[\omega_i]\in \mathcal H^1(U_i)=0$.
The compatibility conditions are trivially satisfied since all intersections $U_i\cap U_j (i\neq j)$ are contractible, so that $\mathcal H^1(U_i\cap U_j )=0$.
Nevertheless we can't glue our cohomology classes $[\omega_i]$ to a global cohomology class $[\omega] \in \mathcal H^1(X)$ since the only global cohomology class on $X$ is $0\in \mathcal H^1(X)=0$, which does not restrict to $[\omega _0]\neq 0\in \mathcal H^1(U_0)$.
Remark
Here too the answer is entirely due to my geometer friend.

Fixed typos and changed tone (as it can unnecessarily make some people feel inadequate)
Source Link
Chris Gerig
  • 17.5k
  • 2
  • 71
  • 116
Loading
Source Link
Georges Elencwajg
  • 47.5k
  • 14
  • 159
  • 241
Loading